What's new

Indian government should hang its head in shame: BBC filmmaker

My thoughts?
I seriously don't have the energy to type it again.

View attachment 201541
couldn't agree more .............. no body has the right to blame a nation for individual crimes which is not only happening in india but in the whole world including pakistan as well .... Both pakistan and india need to cop with this issue sooner than later ... but no other country/media has the right to sensationalize this issue and blame the whole nation for this crime
 
Meanwhile IB is digging deep for evidence and they already has a lot of evidence about the law violation of Udwin and jail
authorities in Tihar.
BBC also going to pay for commercially benefiting an unfortunate tragedy.

Let's throw her in jail and the rapes will stop
 
Thats cool, we have more threads on this documentary than the total members online...
Introspection is good, why get bothered about it when outsiders point it? Isn't this what Liberals wanted, force India to introspect and change it's Rape Culture.
 
Thats cool, we have more threads on this documentary than the total members online...

Happens when you try to do the exact opposite thing. :) Now I'm desperately searching for the smog documentary the Chinese banned :)
 
Given that a German Prof has already made the consequences of such documentaries clear, I think the government is spot on.

There are enough Indian people to tackle Indian problems, we don't need foreign gutter inspectors. Yes we have our problems, but we are dealing with them. Such documentaries don't make any positive contribution to the fight against the evil of rape, but are used as a slander against the image of India. You can see that from the wide coverage given to it on this forum especially by certain posters.

We don't see any such documentaries on the grooming of women in UK which affected a lot of women but limited public outrage, but they have time for covering a single rape in India, which lead to widespread protests.
 
Indian government should hang its head in shame: BBC filmmaker

851408-LESLEE-1426063446-826-640x480.jpg

A day after the sole witness of the Delhi gang rape termed the documentary India’s Daughter ‘fake’, filmmaker Leslee Udwin said the Indian government should hang its head in shame for banning her documentary.

Read: Sole witness of Delhi gang rape claims documentary is fake

“The government should hang its head in shame” for the ban, she was quoted as saying in an interview on before the US premiere of her film at an event in downtown Manhattan, according to India Today.

India banned the BBC documentary on the fatal rape of a 23-year-old woman on a moving bus in Delhi on December 16, 2012. The documentary was banned following an uproar over convicted rapist Mukesh Singh’s comments blaming the victim.

“A girl is far more responsible for rape than a boy,” Mukesh Singh said in an interview from jail.

Read: A girl is far more responsible for rape than a boy, says Delhi bus rapist

Udwin also denied accusations in the Indian media that Mukesh Singh was either paid for his time or interviewed without his consent. A title card at the start of the film refutes the claim.

“The home minister (Rajnath Singh) blamed the protesters when these were protests on the Gandhian level, peaceful and right and good,” Udwin told the Los Angeles Times. “The irony is it only became violent when the police got involved.”

Read: Ban on Delhi gang-rape documentary stirs fierce debate in India

Actresses Meryl Streep, Freida Pinto, Dakota Fanning and singer Chris Martin were among those at the premiere, an event organised by women’s-rights groups Vital Voices and Plan International at Manhattan’s Baruch College.

Streep led a candle-lighting ceremony before the screening, reading some of the victim’s accounts of the assault, then issued a plea to the audience.

Read: India channel protests rape documentary ban with blank screen

“We’re called here to contend with something more than rape,” Streep was quoted as saying.

“What is worse than violence? Violence sanctioned by misogyny.” Pinto, a producer of the movie told the Times in an interview before the screening that she saw this as “a universal story, and something I got involved with because it’s not just about what happens in India”.

Pinto gave an address after the screening in which she criticised even Western attitudes about the Indian gang-rape, noting a TV script she had been sent recently that contained a joke about it.

She also issued a wide-ranging plea to people as diverse policymakers and boys to shift their thinking.

Closing her speech Pinto asked people to close their eyes and be “bathed in the light, the light that was Jyoti.”

Udwin also took the stage after the screening as part of a panel discussion about women’s rights issues.

“The disease is not rape, and the disease is not human trafficking,” she said. “The disease is gender inequality. And all these things are the metastases of the primary tumour.”

Indian government should hang its head in shame: BBC filmmaker – The Express Tribune
She's been called out on her duplictious nature, the shady funding web behind this film, her integrity and the questionable motives behind it so why not blame the GoI?



Reccomend all to watch/read:





Deception, Lies Behind Making of India’s Daughter -The New Indian Express



Where is her answer to this?
 
Introspection is good, why get bothered about it when outsiders point it? Isn't this what Liberals wanted, force India to introspect and change it's Rape Culture.


I am yet to see any meaningful discussion in any of these threads.

Infact the whole world affairs section is full of this.
 
She's been called out on her duplictious nature, the shady funding web behind this film, her integrity and the questionable motives behind it so why not blame the GoI?



Reccomend all to watch/read:





Deception, Lies Behind Making of India’s Daughter -The New Indian Express



Where is her answer to this?

I don't see anything in the documentary that we should not take cognizance of. What we should also look at is stereotyping like German Univ. But there is no reason why we should punish her.
 
I don't see anything in the documentary that we should not take cognizance of. What we should also look at is stereotyping like German Univ. But there is no reason why we should punish her.
Read the article sir and then tell me if she doesn't have a case to answer, she has subverted Indian laws and used shady sources of funding to produce this biased and "fake" (according to the sole trustworthy witness in this incident) documentary, this is not a cae of shoot the messenger but have a person with questionable motives to account for their actions in India.
 
I am yet to see any meaningful discussion in any of these threads.

Infact the whole world affairs section is full of this.
Well I not the mod here don't say that to me.
 
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/12/opinion/censoring-a-film-on-rape.html?_r=0

Ms. Udwin’s film has increased worldwide awareness of attitudes that beget sexual violence against women. India’s government protects those attitudes by preventing its citizens from seeing this reality.

The crux of the problem summed up in one sentence.
Wrong, wrong and wrong again. The Indian government didn't ban this film because it is trying to hide away from the issues in Indian society BUT because there is a serious amount of illegailty involved in both the filming and the airing of this film. As per an agreement between the GoI and BBC they would not telecast it without certain condtions being met but the BBC did not adhere to such agremeents and went ahead and brought foreward the airing of the film.

This is a case of India standing up to the Western NGOs, finacial backers and those who are trying to undermine India.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom