What's new

Why Osama's death is not good news for India

well if pak and china will team up in afghanistan , india can also team up with iran who has similar interests in a stable afg with no taliban (we r not funding chabahar port and highways connecting iran afg for nothing ;) ). its not about winning the war in afghanistan ...india has a favourable image among masses in afg and will use it to its advantage.

buddy !!! these days there are not many things pakistanis can cheer about..let him make up something and feel good about his country
 
If Pakistan had intervened in any way, OBL's supporters would be targetting Pakistan. The only way was for Pakistan to completely get out of the way and let the Americans carry out the operation.

On topic, the analysis is correct. The Indian gloating will turn to hand-wringing as soon as the US hands over the reins of control in Afghanistan to China.

China? wow. i think its a good idea. Chinese are peaceful people. If US join hands with China for development in the region and become more friendly then many issues can be resolved and it would be good US in the long run as well as subcontinent in general.

the SAARC countries can also have a good time and US will be hailed as a supporter and not aggressor
 
well if pak and china will team up in afghanistan , india can also team up with iran who has similar interests in a stable afg with no taliban (we r not funding chabahar port and highways connecting iran afg for nothing ;) ). its not about winning the war in afghanistan ...india has a favourable image among masses in afg and will use it to its advantage.


You are already teamed up with Iran so who is stopping you. its not about teaming up or whatever you may call it.


If China comes into prospect with regards to Afghanistan then Iran can also join the same block it will be a win win situation for US, Iran, China, Afghanistan, Pakistan and equally for India too when the trade is expanded
 
I think Osama hiding in a mansion near Pakistan military academy, is 10 times more damaging to Pak then to India.

This will certainly reduce tourism in Pakistan, less people wanting to travel to Pakistan, even though some say its more beautiful.
 
I think it's a joke that you think you can conduct espionage operations in Pakistan without the US's presence, you don't have the same kinds of links Pakistan has with Afghanistan. Pakistan is 'ethnically the same', the Pashtuns are the highest ethnic population of Afghanistan, & Pakistan has more than twice the number of Pakhtuns in Pakistan. Furthermore, Pakistan & the ISI knows every inch of Afghanistan, knows it inside out. You just don't have the same type of command in Afghanistan. Unfortunately, I see very troubling times for India, as China & Pakistan will team up inside Afghanistan & invest there in its natural resources, which will bring prosperity for the Afghan citizens, as well as maintaining a Pakistan friendly government (probably the Haqqani network sharing power with some other faction). India will be eaten alive if it tries to use Afghanistan soil against Pakistan. If the US couldn't win the war inside Afghanistan, what chance does India has?

All sounds great when every Pakistani speaks for China. Alas, China is definitely smarter than you know and they would never want radical Islam making a grand entry into their territory or have anything to do with it. What makes you think China will be a major player in Afghanistan when they know both US and the Soviets have suffered there? There are more than enough nut jobs in PAK who would wage a Jihad if China every got itself involved.

Its obvious for you being a Pakistani to say US has been a bad ally but I think the world saw after the capture of OBL what a true ally Pakistan has been to the US. China may not be on the same page with the US but don't consider them fools when they read the report card on US-PAK friendship. China is your biggest ally but like all other countries they have their own interests to protect. Radical ISalm thriving in PAK does not help anybody but may be PAK! China will be very aware!!
 
its a very balanced article, as we all know US have already planned to leave Afghanistan within a year & once US leaves this area Al-Qaeda will have no one to fight against ?? and security analyst have already stated that Al-Qaeda have started moving their assets to Africa.. while Yemen being the C & C for Al-Qaeda.. their are also reports circulating that Yemeni Born US Citizen Doc might end up being Al-Qaeda head......
 
If Pakistan had intervened in any way, OBL's supporters would be targetting Pakistan. The only way was for Pakistan to completely get out of the way and let the Americans carry out the operation.

On topic, the analysis is correct. The Indian gloating will turn to hand-wringing as soon as the US hands over the reins of control in Afghanistan to China.

So you would rather have US violate your sovereignty and territorial integrity than Pakistan take action against OBL and their followers. Thats pathetic. This whole operation made Pakistan a laughing stock in front of the world. From now on no one is going to believe any thing coming out of Pakistan. Your reputation is seriously hampered which will take years to repair. Judging by the reaction in some international forums, Westerners are already crying for Pakistan's blood.You will also have a hard time explaining how you spent the billions of dollars that you received from US for fighting terror. And all this for what- A Saudi Yemini who exploited Islam and its beliefs for his own gains and as a result singlehandedly destroyed the reputation of Islam and caused much pain & insecurity for its true followers.
 
If Pakistan had intervened in any way, OBL's supporters would be targetting Pakistan. The only way was for Pakistan to completely get out of the way and let the Americans carry out the operation.

On topic, the analysis is correct. The Indian gloating will turn to hand-wringing as soon as the US hands over the reins of control in Afghanistan to China.

TO CHINA?? again China??

Khair, India has nothing to do with all this stuff. India has nothing to gloat about, our interest with Afghanistan has mostly been humanitarian unlike others...


If Pakistan had intervened in any way, OBL's supporters would be targetting Pakistan. The only way was for Pakistan to completely get out of the way and let the Americans carry out the operation.

So pakistan did not take on OBL because his followers would have targeted pakistan... But i thought mighty pakistani Army could take on and beat a force 3 times larger than it in minutes, then why be scared of rag tag AQ followers,

P.S. Maybe NASR II needs smaller range i.e. few meters ... target some other leaders house few meters from the camp...just joking
 
So you are saying that pakistan intelligence cant move a man without OBL supporters knowing. Thats great accolade for ISI.

OBL isn't just any man. Pakistan didn't want to get involved in any way. Let the Americans come and collect their trophy.

good joke..by the way can u guys ever do something without china??

We kicked India's as$ out of Afghanistan before 9/11.

So you would rather have US violate your sovereignty and territorial integrity than Pakistan take action against OBL and their followers. Thats pathetic. This whole operation made Pakistan a laughing stock in front of the world. From now on no one is going to believe any thing coming out of Pakistan. Your reputation is seriously hampered which will take years to repair. Judging by the reaction in some international forums, Westerners are already crying for Pakistan's blood.You will also have a hard time explaining how you spent the billions of dollars that you received from US for fighting terror. And all this for what- A Saudi Yemini who exploited Islam and its beliefs for his own gains and as a result singlehandedly destroyed the reputation of Islam and caused much pain & insecurity for its true followers.

Please read again: this was not a violation of sovereignty. The American operation happened with Pakistan's knowledge. As for the West, they bark about Pakistan all the time anyway. The most important thing for Pakistan is for the US to leave Afghanistan and that's what Pakistan will get out of this deal.
 
Time to sharpen those reading skills.

TO CHINA?? again China??

This is from the original article, not me.

Khair, India has nothing to do with all this stuff. India has nothing to gloat about, our interest with Afghanistan has mostly been humanitarian unlike others...

Uh huh. Supporting the Northern Alliance was purely a humanitarian gesture no doubt.

So pakistan did not take on OBL because his followers would have targeted pakistan... But i thought mighty pakistani Army could take on and beat a force 3 times larger than it in minutes, then why be scared of rag tag AQ followers,

P.S. Maybe NASR II needs smaller range i.e. few meters ... target some other leaders house few meters from the camp...just joking

Leaving aside your facetious trolling, there is no point in inviting terrorist retaliation upon our population.
 
The 'joint-op' in exchange for Afghanistan is a load of bull.

If ISI traded OBL, they would have handed him over to US probably or the "joint op" would have happened near the Afghanistan border.

What happened here is US caught ISI pants down result in massively bad PR for Pak (OBL 700mtrs from Pak Military academy)
 
Its funny to see Pakistanis planning their next strategic move in kicking India in Afghanistan when their own a$$ was brutally violated by US in the past few days , their credibility as a viable nation at an all time low and various world leaders asking them for 'explanations' on why the world's most wanted terrorist was living comfortably in a a million dollar mansion in a garrison town with a serving Major Gen as the neighbour and just 800 yards from the PMA Kakul. What an ignominy !. If I were a Pakistani I would be hanging my head in shame and be doing some soul-searching instead of writing these brainless trash.Yet.....

And it is double funny to see all this planning including China as if they are the spokesperson for China because they know in their deep hearts that they are nothing without the word "China" appended to Pakistan. :lol:

p.s.; If anyone thinks that the US Afghan exit has started - think again. Now the USG can easily justify their continued presence in Afg by citing their sucess in the case of taking out OBL. Most importantly of all India has weathered 64 summers in Kashmir against all odds and this wont change the situation in Kashmir a bit. If at all we ll have a dozen more jihadi scums trying to cross over. Time to increase bullet production in Ordanance factories.
 
OBL isn't just any man. Pakistan didn't want to get involved in any way. Let the Americans come and collect their trophy.



We kicked India's as$ out of Afghanistan before 9/11.



Please read again: this was not a violation of sovereignty. The American operation happened with Pakistan's knowledge. As for the West, they bark about Pakistan all the time anyway. The most important thing for Pakistan is for the US to leave Afghanistan and that's what Pakistan will get out of this deal.

Let Americans come and take the trophy that too from 800 mtrs from Pakistan Academy. I think your top brass needs mental treatment.
And why you are afraid to touch OBL.90% of the Muslim World hates him. Or is that the other 10% lives in Pakistan.

India never had a presence in Afghanisthan before 9/11 eventhough we were supporting Northern Alliance.

As for "reconquest" of Afghanisthan- How are you planning to do this? Majority of Taliban is now outside your control and I don't think KSA and UAE will not be forthcoming with their petrodollars to fund another Taliban given how much bad publicity they got from the present one. You have to fund this "conquest" all by yourself. Do you have it in you??
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom