What are the historic borders of Jammu & Kashmir?

[VCheng]

Mind sharing what impact this academic point would have

Pakistan and India have been claiming all of Kashmir since their independence, and it seems to me a very basic step should be to determine what exactly are the boundaries of whatever it is they are fighting over?

 

[midnightmasala]

Pakistan and India have been claiming all of Kashmir since their independence, and it seems to me a very basic step should be to determine what exactly are the boundaries of whatever it is they are fighting over?

I would say just keep loc As ib and move on

 

[ifesvr]

Pakistan and India have been claiming all of Kashmir since their independence, and it seems to me a very basic step should be to determine what exactly are the boundaries of whatever it is they are fighting over?

No Pakistan does not claim all of Jammu & Kashmir. They have given up Shaksham valley to China and does not claim the so called "Akshai Chin" !

 

[midnightmasala]

How long do you want to keep fighting? That is the question.

 

[toxic_pus]

See if these help

The Future of Kashmir? "Seven" Possible Solutions! | Page 75

The Future of Kashmir? "Seven" Possible Solutions! | Page 79

 

[VCheng]

See if these help

The Future of Kashmir? "Seven" Possible Solutions! | Page 75

The Future of Kashmir? "Seven" Possible Solutions! | Page 79

It seems to me that what India and Pakistan are fighting over no longer exists, only the fragments.

 

[Force-India]

Pakistan and India have been claiming all of Kashmir since their independence, and it seems to me a very basic step should be to determine what exactly are the boundaries of whatever it is they are fighting over?

m.youtube.com/watch?v=QlI5yArLvLU

 

[VCheng]

m.youtube.com/watch?v=QlI5yArLvLU

That is a pretty basic view of the whole issue.

 

[Force-India]

That is a pretty basic view of the whole issue.

Yep and you can see the area disputed in the video.

 

[KingMamba]

Yep and you can see the area disputed in the video.

I would take those people's views with a grain of salt, they did not even know what Hindus were in one video. Instead they called Hindus, Hindis and then they want to talk about Indian and Pakistani problem lol.

 

[chathrapathi]

This seems like the correct place to ask a simple question that came to my mind:

What are the historic borders of Jammu & Kashmir as of 14 August, 1947?

LOL....History goes only as long as 1947 for you!!!

 

[Force-India]

I would take those people's views with a grain of salt, they did not even know what Hindus were in one video. Instead they called Hindus, Hindis and then they want to talk about Indian and Pakistani problem lol.

This one is accurate though.

 

[VCheng]

LOL....History goes only as long as 1947 for you!!!

Well, 1947 is the start of the fight over Kashmir, hence the date I picked.

 

[toxic_pus]

It seems to me that what India and Pakistan are fighting over no longer exists, only the fragments.

...and what exactly do you think India and Pakistan are really fighting over?

 

[VCheng]

...and what exactly do you think India and Pakistan are really fighting over?

Isn't Kashmir recognized to be the core issue between the two countries?