What's new

Under Imran's govt, Pakistan's trade deficit narrows 33.5%

Shahzaz ud din

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 12, 2017
7,877
14
13,321
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
Under Imran's govt, Pakistan's trade deficit narrows 33.5%
By Salman Siddiqui
Published: November 15, 2019
TWEET EMAIL
2099824-tradereuters-1573784800-893-640x480.jpg

Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS

KARACHI: Pakistan’s trade deficit narrowed 33.52% to $7.77 billion in first four months (Jul-Oct) of the current fiscal year due to a notable contraction in imports.

Measures taken to address imbalances in the economy over the past two years such as rupee depreciation, hike in the benchmark interest rate and higher regulatory duty on imports helped improve the balance of trade but badly impacted industrial activities and slowed down economic growth.

The Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) reported that imports dropped 19.21% to $15.32 billion in first four months of fiscal year 2019-20 compared to $18.96 billion in the same period of previous fiscal year. Exports crawled up 3.81% to $7.54 billion in the four-month period against expectations of annualised growth of over 8%. Exports stood at $7.27 billion in the corresponding period of last year, according to the PBS.
“Had the government managed to slash imports considerably, the trade deficit would have also contracted considerably,” remarked JS Global Head of Research Hussain Haider while talking to The Express Tribune.

He argued that still supermarkets were full of imported goods. Anyone could name an imported product and he would find it in markets and malls, he said.

“The trade deficit figure is not surprising. It is largely in line with market expectations,” he pointed out. “The number would have surprised us had it been better than our expectations.”

The corrective measures have so far remained ineffective in helping achieve a meaningful growth in exports in dollar terms. Exports remained sluggish due to the prevailing low product prices in world markets amid a global economic slowdown, said central bank officials recently.

“However, exports of some of the sectors have surged up to 40% in volumetric terms,” State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) Governor Reza Baqir said this week. A drop in worker remittances over the past couple of months against expectations of a notable increase has brought a new challenge for the economic managers striving to restrict the current account deficit. The balance of trade also remains a key element in narrowing down the current account deficit.

Haider was of the view that the reduction in trade deficit in Jul-Oct 2019 was not an achievement to celebrate. “The economy has remained in a slowdown mode,” he argued.

3-1573758359.jpg


The central bank has projected gross domestic product (GDP) growth of 3.5% for FY20, which is close to a nine-year low of 3.3% hit in the preceding fiscal year.

“The current account deficit and trade deficit have narrowed significantly but these improvements do not reflect in the country’s foreign currency reserves,” he said.

“They (reserves) are standing at $8.3 billion. This is the same level last seen in August,” he said and added that huge foreign debt repayments were consuming the reserves at a rapid pace.

According to him, the government needs to act and eliminate unwanted imports sooner rather than later.

“Pakistan is scheduled to make a big foreign debt repayment in December…the next tranche of IMF (International Monetary Fund) loan worth $450 million may help rebalance the reserves,” he pointed out.

He added that the data of first three months of FY20 suggested that imports had indeed dropped including those of machinery, petroleum, chemical, agricultural and metals groups due to the government’s corrective policy measures.

He cheered that textile remained the largest export industry of Pakistan, which was trying to perform better after the PTI government and the previous PML-N administration let the rupee depreciate massively. The IMF has projected that the trade deficit in the current fiscal year will narrow down to $24.8 billion. The projection is based on an 8.2% increase in exports and 4.7% contraction in imports.

The return of stability to the rupee-dollar parity and an extended rally at the Pakistan Stock Exchange were hinting at the return of good days soon, Haider said.

Published in The Express Tribune, November 15th, 2019.

Like Business on Facebook, follow @TribuneBiz on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.


Read more: Business , economy , exports
 
Why not just impose an all out ban on imports, then Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf can brag about having $25 billion surplus?

Decrease in imports does not mean increase in exports but instead it causes shortage of supplies and increase in prices for the ordinary people.
 
Why not just impose an all out ban on imports, then Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf can brag about having $25 billion surplus?

Decrease in imports does not mean increase in exports but instead it causes shortage of supplies and increase in prices for the ordinary people.

It depends on which imports were reduced, some things like oil, machinery, electronics etc. we need to import, but we were also importing a lot of useless things like agricultural products, textiles, and other goods which are widely produced in Pakistan just so traders can save a few pennies.
 
It depends on which imports were reduced, some things like oil, machinery, electronics etc. we need to import, but we were also importing a lot of useless things like agricultural products, textiles, and other goods which are widely produced in Pakistan just so traders can save a few pennies.

Those "useless" things were being imported because the supply could not meet the demand and it helped the ordinary man.

Now, as soon as Pakistan reduced imports it suddenly increased prices for everyone simply because the industry in Pakistan for those "useless" things wasn't large enough to meet the demand.

As has been proven, restrictions on imports hasn't magically enlarged Pakistan's industry even after 15-months but instead it has increased unemployment, hampered economic growth and stagnated what little industry that existed in Pakistan as a whole.
 
Those "useless" things were being imported because the supply could not meet the demand and it helped the ordinary man.

Now, as soon as Pakistan reduced imports it suddenly increased prices for everyone simply because the industry in Pakistan for those "useless" things wasn't large enough to meet the demand.

Not always, only essential goods need to be imported, almost every economist will agree that unrestricted import policies slow down growth and lead to stagnation. The price of goods for now has gone up because of the currency, that applies to everything including exports, so not related to the import policy.

As has been proven, restrictions on imports hasn't magically enlarged Pakistan's industry even after 15-months but instead it has increased unemployment, hampered economic growth and stagnated what little industry that existed in Pakistan as a whole.

Thats not true, the economy is showing indications of growth, and considering how close Pakistan was to full bankruptcy thats a very good indication in a relatively short amount of time. 5-10 years from now the economy will be looking much better than it has been for a while.
 
Why not just impose an all out ban on imports, then Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf can brag about having $25 billion surplus?

Decrease in imports does not mean increase in exports but instead it causes shortage of supplies and increase in prices for the ordinary people.

Main commodities of imports during February, 2018 were Petroleum products (Rs.51,337 million), Petroleum crude (Rs.41,665 million), Natural gas, liquified ( Rs.28,357 million), Iron & steel (Rs.23,033 million), Raw cotton (Rs.22,442 million), Plastic materials (Rs.21,498 million), Power generating machinery (Rs.19,560 million), Electrical machinery & apparatus (Rs.19,166 million), Palm oil (Rs.15,152 million), Iron & steel scrap ( Rs.11,300 million).

Which of them can be banned?
 
Main commodities of imports during February, 2018 were Petroleum products (Rs.51,337 million), Petroleum crude (Rs.41,665 million), Natural gas, liquified ( Rs.28,357 million), Iron & steel (Rs.23,033 million), Raw cotton (Rs.22,442 million), Plastic materials (Rs.21,498 million), Power generating machinery (Rs.19,560 million), Electrical machinery & apparatus (Rs.19,166 million), Palm oil (Rs.15,152 million), Iron & steel scrap ( Rs.11,300 million).

Which of them can be banned?

I don't know, ask Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf. They were of the view restricting imports will help the local industry but the opposite has taken place for the last 15-months.

I don't think Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf's attempt to re-invent the wheel has gone according to plan.
 
I don't know, ask Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf. They were of the view restricting imports will help the local industry but the opposite has taken place for the last 15-months.

I don't think Pakistan Tehrik-e-Insaf's attempt to re-invent the wheel has gone according to plan.

Problem is not the imports, its exports that Pakistan need to work on.
 
“Pakistan is scheduled to make a big foreign debt repayment in December…the next tranche of IMF (International Monetary Fund) loan worth $450 million may help rebalance the reserves,” he pointed out.


So Pakistan is taking more loans in order to pay the old loans... This doesn't sound sustainable.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 2, Members: 0, Guests: 2)


Back
Top Bottom