What's new

Top Indian scientist calls for halt to Nuclear power

Lankan Ranger

ELITE MEMBER
Aug 9, 2009
12,550
0
7,961
Top Indian scientist calls for halt to Nuclear power

A top scientist on the Prime Minister’s scientific advisory council on Thursday demanded a nuclear moratorium following the Fukushima nuclear plant disaster in quake-ravaged Japan.

This is the first direct call from within the government for a temporary stop to nuclear power production. P Balaram, director of the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, and member of the scientific advisory council to the PM, has joined a growing group of scientists and activists seeking a review of India's nuclear strategy.

"In the light of what has happened in Japan, I believe completely transparent safety audits are required for all nuclear projects. The nuclear regulator must also be completely independent of the department of atomic energy (DAE),” Balaram told HT over the phone.

Several scientists and activists had Wednesday issued a statement seeking a review of India’s nuclear policy.

But unlike others, Balaram’s demand for a moratorium — stopping nuclear power production for the time being — is likely to embarrass the government because of the positions he holds.

Manmohan Singh and the nuclear establishment have emphatically ruled out a moratorium - though the Prime Minister Wednesday did propose greater transparency in decisions regarding nuclear plants.

India's nuclear power regulator - the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board - reports to the DAE, which is in charge of approving projects, creating a potential conflict of interest.

Though most countries have announced safety reviews of their nuclear plants following the Fukushima radiation leak, Germany is the only country to opt for a temporary moratorium. It has shut down seven aging plants.

Balaram said he agreed to be a co-signatory to a petition seeking a nuclear moratorium because many of India's proposed nuclear plants were likely to come up in populated and ecologically sensitive areas.

Top scientist calls for halt to N-power - Hindustan Times
 
India has the worst nuclear power regulation policies. This is self evident if you look back to the issue at tarapur nuclear plant. The scientists refused to let indira gandhi ( then prime minister) shut down the plant eveb when evidences of a radioactive leak were quite evident. Everytime indira tried to shut the plant down, the scientist at tarapur pleaded and begged her to not close it down. They said it would harm the indigenous nuclear industry.

Homi suggested nuclear and space programmes of india be considered as national secrets which enabled the regulatory bodies to do what they wanted without public scrutiny.

About tarapur, that plant has been an eyesore in the indian nuclear industry. Back in the sixties they had a major leak which they managed to hide from the primeminister successfully for quite a period. The scientists worked in cycle shifts trying to fix the weak links exposing themselves to significant amounts of radiation. Finally they managed to contain it ,but not without casualities. The civilians affected, were treated in secret.

What im driving at, is that indian nuclear industry has a thick veil of secrecy over it. Secrecy enables them to carry out controversial projects and experiments under the radar.

India desperately needs stronger regulations and a motion must be forwarded to address this issue.
 
The folks from DAE does not understand the meaning of transparecy or accountability. Our nuclear programme is not a startup to be shrouded in secrecy....we have a mature nuclear industry now.
 
NP is okay! we already have too many people..if few die then doesn't matter....our NPs are in a peninsula so radiation will get dispersed plus we already have very low IQ so further scope of mental retardation is not there.
 
NP is okay! we already have too many people..if few die then doesn't matter....our NPs are in a peninsula so radiation will get dispersed plus we already have very low IQ so further scope of mental retardation is not there.

I would shudder at the loss of any human life..
and being away from population center's does not mean you wont get affected.. consider the Japan example.. the radiation from the plant made it as far as germany.. the environmental impact of it is enormous.. after all, when all the wars are fought.. and all is done. You will still have to stay on this earth.
 
India didn't go down the path of mass-industralization, so they don't require as much energy as we do.

we dont need energy as much as you do as of now but we need to provide the people of india and industrial unit at present and in the future with adequate electricity,nuclear energy is a cleaner energy so that will help the environment and provide electricity to all the villages,cities in india
 
BARC and IGCAR does not come under IAEA sanctions and a lot of research is done in these places. Those are not disclosed to anyone. it is a closely gaurded secret.
 
The contribution of the nuclear sector of the total power in India is less than 5% of the total.... I really think we need to improve on this sector.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 2, Members: 0, Guests: 2)


Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom