Stranded Pakistanis in Ctg owe PDB Tk 300m as bills

[TopCat]

That's still a fair deal; our population would go down by several million.

Not going to help you as you will fill that up in no time with your current fertility rate.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

That was your choice then , those bangalis loved pakistan, these Biharis are Pakistani they fought on behalf of Pakistan's army.

I am sure many of those socalled 'Bengali' in Karachi are not actually Bengali but Bihari. Both Bengali and Bihari in karachi speak Urdu. Came from the same destination. Even in Bangladesh, one can not distinguish between a Bengali and Bihari, if that Bihari person speak Bengali. So how come native Pakistanis are able to distinguish who is Bengali and who is Bihari when both speak Urdu? I am sure, most of these ''3 million Bengali' in Karachi are actually Bihari. Bengali is a blanket term in Pakistan for anyone who came from Bangladesh it appear.

Before 1971, half a million Bengalis lived in West pakistan. After the war, they became stranded and held hostage by Pakistani govt. Many of them then escaped to Afghanistan and Iran to came back in Bangladesh. After 1974 treaty, most of those half a million stranded Bengali returned to Bangladesh. They were not lured by Pakistani ''prosperity'' to stay back. So, it sound ridiculous that after their return a new wave of Bangladeshi gone there in millions of number despite Pakistan became a distant, alien country.

 

[TopCat]

I am sure many of those socalled 'Bengali' in Karachi are not actually Bengali but Bihari. Both Bengali and Bihari in karachi speak Urdu. Came from the same destination. Even in Bangladesh, one can not distinguish between a Bengali and Bihari, if that Bihari person speak Bengali. So how come native Pakistanis are able to distinguish who is Bengali and who is Bihari when both speak Urdu? I am sure, most of these ''3 million Bengali' in Karachi are actually Bihari.

Before 1971, half a million Bengalis lived in West pakistan. After the war, they became stranded and held hostage by Pakistani govt. Many of them then escaped to Afghanistan and Iran to came back in Bangladesh. After 1974 treaty, most of those half a million stranded Bengali returned to Bangladesh. They were not lured by Pakistani ''prosperity'' to stay back. So, it sound ridiculous that after their return a new wave of Bangladeshi gone there in millions of number despite Pakistan became a distant, alien country.

There were Bengali fisherman in Karachi since British colonial time. Then came the Ayub who also took some Bengalis from here and settle them in Karachi.
But it would had been better if they got back to BD after 1971. But it was hard for the people who moved directly from Indian bengal to west pakistan instead of east paskistan as they did not have anywhere to come back to.

 

[Pakistansdefender]

Kill them all Pakistanis and be done with it.

 

[American Pakistani]

That was your choice then , those bangalis loved pakistan, these Biharis are Pakistani they fought on behalf of Pakistan's army.

Those Bangladeshis love Pakistan as much as Bangladeshis in North east and else where in india love india, or as Mexicans love US.

So a fair deal, they give us those 8000 Biharis and take 3 million bangladeshis illegally living in Pakistan. Note that those Biharis are given citizenship of Bangladesh by Bangladeshi courts which makes them Bangladeshis now but still.

 

[Mage]

So a fair deal, they give us those 8000 Biharis and take 3 million bangladeshis illegally living in Pakistan. Note that those Biharis are given citizenship of Bangladesh by Bangladeshi courts which makes them Bangladeshis now but still.

Why just those 8000? You gotta take all the Biharis in Bangladesh.

Do you mean to say that the govt of Pakistan should pay the bills for their citizens living in BD? Not a bad idea, though!!

With their current situation, govt of Pakistan is more likely ask donations from them.

 

[American Pakistani]

Why just those 8000? You gotta take all the Biharis in Bangladesh.

Yes a fair deal all those who migrated to East Pakistan before 71.

I'm sure they are not more than 500K.

With their current situation, govt of Pakistan is more likely ask donations from them.

It's still better than govt of Bangladesh who sold it's women to highest bidder (forget about men who are like slave while at work and have no workers right).

 

[Mage]

Yes a fair deal all those who migrated to East Pakistan before 71.

You give us Bengalis and we return you Urdu speaking guys who were always loyal to Pak. It doesn't get more fair than that.

 

[American Pakistani]

You give us Bengalis and we return you Urdu speaking guys who were always loyal to Pak. It doesn't get more fair than that.

I hope this happens.

 

[Bilal9]

Why just these 8000? Biharis in Bangladesh number around a Million. Let's exchange the whole lots.

Biharis used to WANT to go to Pakistan. Lately their kids learned Bangla and assimilated (some completely dissociated from their own community). Now they changed their tune and DON'T want to go.

 

[Bilal9]

Not going to help you as you will fill that up in no time with your current fertility rate.

Well I have to agree that this is accurate.

Runaway Fertility rate and population growth is something Pakistan seriously has to work on. I am saying this as a well-wisher for Pakistan.

I am hopeful that our BRAC NGO can help somewhat and replicate our successes in Pakistan as well.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/154346-pakistans-population-growth-is-a-ticking-time-bomb

http://www.bracinternational.nl/en/where-we-work/pakistan/

Jar keu nai tar asey Allah. Sad.

 

[Viking 63]

Bring all the Biharis from Bangladesh and deport all Bengalis from Pakistan. win win situation.!!

 

[American Pakistani]

Well I have to agree that this is accurate.

Runaway Fertility rate and population growth is something Pakistan seriously has to work on. I am saying this as a well-wisher for Pakistan.

I am hopeful that our BRAC NGO can help somewhat and replicate our successes in Pakistan as well.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/154346-pakistans-population-growth-is-a-ticking-time-bomb

http://www.bracinternational.nl/en/where-we-work/pakistan/

Jar keu nai tar asey Allah. Sad.

Thanks for your well wishing. But just to keep you educated, this Brac NGO school is located in Orangi town which is the hub of illegal Bangladeshis and many Rohingyas.

I don't know being super hospitable and open heart is a blessing or curse for Pakistan, my country men has welcomed people no matter which nation or ethnic background they are from, even after being a poor country. But thanks to countries like Bangladesh and Afghanistan, we are soon learning the ugly reality.

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

Not going to help you as you will fill that up in no time with your current fertility rate.

Oh yes it definitely will, the Bengalis here are notorious for their "breeding capabilities"

I am sure many of those socalled 'Bengali' in Karachi are not actually Bengali but Bihari. Both Bengali and Bihari in karachi speak Urdu. Came from the same destination. Even in Bangladesh, one can not distinguish between a Bengali and Bihari, if that Bihari person speak Bengali. So how come native Pakistanis are able to distinguish who is Bengali and who is Bihari when both speak Urdu? I am sure, most of these ''3 million Bengali' in Karachi are actually Bihari. Bengali is a blanket term in Pakistan for anyone who came from Bangladesh it appear.

That's your own speculation.

It's well known who these migrants are. They speak Bengali and they refer to themselves as Bengali, they live in areas called Bengali colonies. There are separate Bihari colonies.

There are also hundreds of thousands of Rohingya who passed through Bangladesh to get to Pakistan, they aren't included as a part of the Bengali population.

Well I have to agree that this is accurate.

Runaway Fertility rate and population growth is something Pakistan seriously has to work on. I am saying this as a well-wisher for Pakistan.

I am hopeful that our BRAC NGO can help somewhat and replicate our successes in Pakistan as well.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/154346-pakistans-population-growth-is-a-ticking-time-bomb

http://www.bracinternational.nl/en/where-we-work/pakistan/

Jar keu nai tar asey Allah. Sad.

Guess where most of those kids are from?

Before 1971, half a million Bengalis lived in West pakistan. After the war, they became stranded and held hostage by Pakistani govt. Many of them then escaped to Afghanistan and Iran to came back in Bangladesh. After 1974 treaty, most of those half a million stranded Bengali returned to Bangladesh. They were not lured by Pakistani ''prosperity'' to stay back. So, it sound ridiculous that after their return a new wave of Bangladeshi gone there in millions of number despite Pakistan became a distant, alien country.

It had nothing to do with "prosperity". Bengalis that were here before 1971 were given a choice to stay or leave, many left because a majority of their families were in Bangladesh.

There were Bengali fisherman in Karachi since British colonial time. Then came the Ayub who also took some Bengalis from here and settle them in Karachi.
But it would had been better if they got back to BD after 1971. But it was hard for the people who moved directly from Indian bengal to west pakistan instead of east paskistan as they did not have anywhere to come back to.

Bengalis that were here before 1971 were given a choice of migration or citizenship. The Bengalis and Biharis that migrated to Pakistan during 1971 or shortly after; were given citizenship, land and pension. They have integrated into society.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

Well I have to agree that this is accurate.

Runaway Fertility rate and population growth is something Pakistan seriously has to work on. I am saying this as a well-wisher for Pakistan.

I am hopeful that our BRAC NGO can help somewhat and replicate our successes in Pakistan as well.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/154346-pakistans-population-growth-is-a-ticking-time-bomb

http://www.bracinternational.nl/en/where-we-work/pakistan/

Jar keu nai tar asey Allah. Sad.

That's not your problem now is it? Ur country or should I say the rogue pakistani province is sinking each year.

Thanks for your well wishing. But just to keep you updated, this Brac NGO school is located in Orange town which is the hub of illegal Bangladeshis and many Rohingyas.

I don't know being super hospitable and open heart is a blessing or curse for Pakistan, my country men has welcomed people no matter which nation or ethnic background they are from, even after being a poor country. But thanks to countries like Bangladesh and Afghanistan, we are soon learning the ugly reality.

Curse, kick them out. We have our own issues. Once we solve those we will consider refugees, enough is enough.