Should South Sindh be made a New Provence?

[American Pakistani]

Should Southern Sindh be made a new Provence with Karachi,Hyderabad & Jamshoro it's divisions/districts.

As we all know that these PPP thugs & their waderas will not let South Sindhis(Karachities/Muhajirs/Urduspeakers) peacefully (as we see death toll had climbed triple figure i.e 100) & eat all Sindh provence budget which actually comes due to Karachi so i would like to know sincere opinions from fellow Pakistani brothers.

Please do not troll in this thread.

 

[VCheng]

I think this is an issue for the people living there to decide following proper process, not for expats like to pontificate on. (Just my opinion.)

 

[American Pakistani]

I think this is an issue for the people living there to decide following proper process, not for expats like to pontificate on. (Just my opinion.)

Sorry Sir, but i beleive whereever i live my motherland is Pakistan & my city is Karachi, whatever happens there effects me.

 

[ice_man]

The thing is simple divide pakistan into many provinces BUT not on ethnic grounds but administrative grounds! this will help the common man!

 

[VCheng]

Sorry Sir, but i beleive whereever i live my motherland is Pakistan & my city is Karachi, whatever happens there effects me.

I can respect that too, but people living there view those of us living in the US with great suspicion as to our motives, as you are liable to found out soon enough once they start posting.

 

[American Pakistani]

The thing is simple divide pakistan into many provinces BUT not on ethnic grounds but administrative grounds! this will help the common man!

It won't be ethnic grounds as there are many Pukhtoons,Punjabis,Balochs,Kashmiris & Sindhis are living in Karachi.

Also PPP who is voted by interior Sindh will be exposed to them if these illiterates failed to deliver them roti,kapra,makaan. Also PPP will be under pressure to develop Sukkur or Larkana(any one choosen capital) as major city.

 

[Gentle Typhoon]

Smaller states are better IMO, USA has 1/3 of India’s population, and 50 States. Whereas U.P. (Uttar Pradesh) has population of 166 million! If a citizen in western UP were to be heard in any of the state commissions or courts, he has to travel over 600 km to Lucknow. Given poor infrastructure in South Asia, small states make better sense. Also we have so many accents, dialects in Sub continent, every 200km you travel represent a totally different lifestyle, culture and even language.

Indian Punjab was split into three - Himachal Pradesh, Haryana and Punjab— and all of these are better off. Before the division, Haryana was the poorer part of Punjab.

New South Sindh will certainly improve the quality of governance and lead to better use of economic resources in each of Sindh's regions.

Investors will have more options based on good and promising administation. Right now they are stuck to 4/5 states and Chief Ministers in Pakistan?