Indus civilization and the test of behavioural resemblance

[satvikAcer]

When fifty percent people migrated from Pakistan in 1947 then how is it that they have less Connection to the land than pervez musharaf or salim malik

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

Claim the Indus? Lol - considering it passes through India, I wonder why not?

Around 3% of the Indus passes through India while around 2% of it also passes through China - so does that mean that China should start claiming the Indus Valley Civilization?

The Nile River passes through 11 countries, yet it's civilization is accredited to Egypt.

Just like Brits can't claim the Roman Empire based on some Roman remains in the UK, the Pakistanis should have some sense of self-respect and stop claiming a civilization with which they have no ties.

What kind of an absurd, uncorrelated and inapplicable example is that? Do you even know where the Indus is? or has your schools begin to teach you that it's a river in South India now.

That example should apply to you, not us. Just because you have a couple remains doesn't mean you can claim our civilization. The two most well known and main cities Harappa (Para Munda) and Mohenjodaro (Meluha), are all in Pakistan.

When fifty percent people migrated from Pakistan in 1947 then how is it that they have less Connection to the land than pervez musharaf or salim malik

Where did they teach you this?

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.

And let me remind you, here the ignorer is certainly not a Bharti.

@Kaptaan @django @Talwar e Pakistan @LoveIcon @Max @save_ghenda @Whirling_dervesh @Mugwop

 

[django]

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.

And let me remind you, here the ignorer is certainly not a Bharti.

@Kaptaan @django @Talwar e Pakistan @LoveIcon @Max @save_ghenda @Whirling_dervesh @Mugwop

@Talwar e Pakistan and @Kaptaan have thoroughly exposed your pathetic arguments, no need for any more argument.Log off young fellow.

 

[Jackdaws]

Around 3% of the Indus passes through India while around 2% of it also passes through China - so does that mean that China should start claiming the Indus Valley Civilization?

The Nile River passes through 11 countries, yet it's civilization is accredited to Egypt.


What kind of an absurd, uncorrelated and inapplicable example is that? Do you even know where the Indus is? or has your schools begin to teach you that it's a river in South India now.

That example should apply to you, not us. Just because you have a couple remains doesn't mean you can claim our civilization. The two most well known and main cities Harappa (Para Munda) and Mohenjodaro (Meluha), are all in Pakistan.


Where did they teach you this?

LOL - the education from a madrassa! I will give you a better analogy - Pakistanis claiming credit for IVC is like Christians and European descent people in Mexico claiming credit for the Aztec Civilization simply because they outnumber them now. Thankfully, the Mexicans have more perspective and in general better educated than that; not to mention they also have a modicum of self-respect. Islam and Pakistan have nothing at all to do with the IVC - part of the IVC happens to be in the modern nation-state of Pakistan.

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

LOL - the education from a madrassa! I will give you a better analogy

I have already debunked you with genetic, geographic, historic, cartographic and so much more proofs - yet you continue to be in denial through your narrow-mindedness ignorance. You have been brain-washed beyond repair and that is something I can do nothing about. Your examples have been refuted multiple times over, all your doing is repeating them in different wording.

Pakistanis claiming credit for IVC is like Christians and European descent people in Mexico claiming credit for the Aztec Civilization simply because they outnumber them now.

That example is easily invalidated through genetic proof.

Islam

have nothing at all to do with the IVC

We never said it did. Islam had nothing to do with the Egyptian Civilization, but Egyptians do - same can be said for Pakistanis and IVC.

India is like some self-loathing country in the far corners of Africa trying to claim the Nile civilizations.

part of the IVC happens to be in the modern nation-state of Pakistan.

'Part'...? IVC made up over 90% (98% in late phase) of Pakistan and less than around 1-3% of India (which were mostly dependant colonies).

LOL - the education from a madrassa!

Personal insults, phase 3 of Indian denial, noted.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

I have already debunked you with genetic, geographic, historic, cartographic and so much more proofs - yet you continue to be in denial through your narrow-mindedness ignorance. You have been brain-washed beyond repair and that is something I can do nothing about. Your examples have been refuted multiple times over, all your doing is repeating them in different wording.

May we know the source of this genetic, geographic, historic, cartographic studies?

And may I ask why you take the words of Westerners - many of whom are racists - at face value?

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

May we know the source of this genetic, geographic, historic, cartographic studies?

I've posted them a hundred times, even Kaptaan has. If you care to scroll up and also check the previous thread. Instead you ignore this and continue making spineless claims on IVC.

And may I ask why you take the words of Westerners - many of whom are racists - at face value?

More reliable than Indians

 

[Jackdaws]

I have already debunked you with genetic, geographic, historic, cartographic and so much more proofs - yet you continue to be in denial through your narrow-mindedness ignorance. You have been brain-washed beyond repair and that is something I can do nothing about. Your examples have been refuted multiple times over, all your doing is repeating them in different wording.


That example is easily invalidated through genetic proof.



We never said it did. Islam had nothing to do with the Egyptian Civilization, but Egyptians do - same can be said for Pakistanis and IVC.

India is like some self-loathing country in the far corners of Africa trying to claim the Nile civilizations.


'Part'...? IVC made up over 90% (98% in late phase) of Pakistan and less than around 1-3% of India (which were mostly dependant colonies).


Personal insults, phase 3 of Indian denial, noted.

Pakistan is a modern nation-state created in 1947. The largest IVC town is Rakhigarhi is present day India. Given Pakistan's puny size compared to India obviously the IVC comprises a significant portion of present-day Pak. If Pak still had East Pakistan and Jinnah had gotten his wish of a corridor joining East and West Pakistan, then things would be a bit different.

 

[xyxmt]

LOL - the education from a madrassa! I will give you a better analogy - Pakistanis claiming credit for IVC is like Christians and European descent people in Mexico claiming credit for the Aztec Civilization simply because they outnumber them now. Thankfully, the Mexicans have more perspective and in general better educated than that; not to mention they also have a modicum of self-respect. Islam and Pakistan have nothing at all to do with the IVC - part of the IVC happens to be in the modern nation-state of Pakistan.

I only use one comparison, Just look at each other and decide, no need to study genes or history. Jinnah used the religion to divide India, he could have easily asked for separate land based of how different we look.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

@Kaptaan @django @Talwar e Pakistan
@LoveIcon
@Max @save_ghenda

@Whirling_dervesh
@Mugwop

Stop trusting Western sources. You would do well to understand that West is virulently biased against countries like Iran and India. They (Westerners) have something against Iran and India. You don't believe me? I will state two proofs:

1. Ask YOUR Iranian brothern about how correct Western sources are on the subject of Iran-Iraq war.

2. Have you seen the movie'Slumdog Millionaire'? Isn't the movie very strange? Doesn't it show that Westerners are biased against India?

 

[Jackdaws]

What a pathetic analogy.

Pakistanis claiming IVC would be like Christian Europeans claiming pre-Christian Europe.

Pakistanis claiming IVC would be like Christian Mexicans claiming pre-Christian Mexico.

That's logical isn't it? Unless your schools only focus on open defecation and rape.

India claiming IVC is like black Sudan claiming white Egyptian history.

As mentioned, the biggest township ever found in IVC is in India. I have not seen Brits proudly lay claim to the Roman civilization.

 

[Mamluk]

As mentioned, the biggest township ever found in IVC is in India. I have not seen Brits proudly lay claim to the Roman civilization.

Most of the area is in Pakistan. Biggest or smallest, you only have a handful of them.

Besides, Constantinople is in Turkey. But Turks don't claim to be Greeks.

Is there nothing to be proud of with Ganga/Deccan history? Stop leeching off others' ancient history.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

They (Westerners) have something against Iran and India

What a idiot. The most hated countries by West are Iran, Pakistan and Afghanistan. India comes in as a darling of the West. Where have you been living? On Mars.

 

[Mentee]

What a idiot. The most hated countries by West are Iran, Pakistan and Afghanistan. India comes in as a darling of the West. Where have you been living? On Mars.

Not mars but a desperate attempt to gain Iranian posters sympathy against Pak or of anyone's for that matter