What's new

India’s new citizenship law unnecessary, says Sheikh Hasina

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Dec 31, 2010
10,032
-5
14,469
India’s new citizenship law unnecessary, says Sheikh Hasina


Kallol Bhattacherjee
NEW DELHI, JANUARY 19, 2020 12:48 IST
UPDATED: JANUARY 19, 2020 12:58 IST

https://www.thehindu.com/news/natio...essary-says-sheikh-hasina/article30599102.ece

‘It is an internal affair. Bangladesh has always maintained that the CAA and NRC are internal matters of India,’ says Bangladesh Prime Minister


India’s new citizenship law that aims to give rights to minority communities of Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Pakistan was not necessary, Prime Minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina has said.

In a newspaper interview, she said Prime Minister Narendra Modi had personally assured her that the National Register of Citizens (NRC) was an internal matter of India that would not affect her people.

“We don’t understand why (the Indian government) did it. It was not necessary,” Ms. Hasina told Gulf News in Abu Dhabi where she held high-level meetings. The statement is the first by the Prime Minister of Bangladesh since the controversial law, that has triggered protests across India, was cleared by the Rajya Sabha on December 11.

During the parliamentary debates, Home Minister Amit Shah repeatedly referred to persecution faced by minority communities, mainly the Hindus, in Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan arguing that these groups should get citizenship rights in India. Ms. Hasina distanced her country from the line taken by the Indian government.

“It is an internal affair. Bangladesh has always maintained that the CAA and NRC are internal matters of India. The government of India, on their part, has also repeatedly maintained that the NRC is an internal exercise of India, and Prime Minister Narendra Modi has in person assured me of the same during my visit to New Delhi in October 2019,” she said during the interview.

Ms. Hasina’s government has said that minority communities did not leave her country because of persecution and maintained that there is no reverse migration from India either. “But within India, people are facing many problems,” she declared.

Subsequent to the enactment of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2019, Bangladesh cancelled several high-level meetings to India that included the visits of Foreign Minister A.K. Abdul Momen, Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan among others. Last week, Dhaka cancelled the visit of its State Minister for Foreign Affairs Shahriar Alam, who was to address the Raisina Dialogue.

Ms. Hasina highlighted the burden that Myanmar’s Rohingya refugees were placing on her country and said that the continued presence of the million plus Rohingya in Bangladesh would affect security and stability in the South Asian region. Experts and commentators in Dhaka have expressed concern that the CAA could trigger a Rohingya-like wave of migration to Bangladesh from India. The Ministry of External Affairs is yet to respond to the comment from the leader of Bangladesh.
 
Read it earlier. If Modi has said that it's an internal exercise then where will the new stateless persons go.
 
So India wants to conduct an NRC because these "infiltrators" are a burden on their economy, but then wants to put them in detention centres run by tax money?

Apparently. In any case, in my opinion, whatever India is claiming, they wouldn't be able to execute it on a mass scale. Ultimately, this whole issue will fizzle out. However, it could be, that because of this drive, a number of illegal immigrants, from Bangladesh, start returning, on their own.
 
Last edited:
Apparently, In any case, in my opinion, whatever India is claiming, they wouldn't be able to execute it on a mass scale. Ultimately, this whole issue will fizzle out. However, it could be, that because of this drive, a number of illegal immigrants, from Bangladesh, start returning, on their own.

No more than some thousands illegal BD'shi Muslims are in India.
Whole exercise is BJP nationalistic PR.
 
The new citizenship law isnt that bad for BD. NRC and CAA combination means population swap between BD and India. While it insures less number people will come from India but larger numbers will move out. The Hindu population is burden of BD. Them living in BD means fifth column is active inside while Indian invasion remains a threat in the name of saving them. And they choosing affairs which doesnt suit BD at all, security risks of them selling secrets of BD, humiliating BD home aborad, while most are too corrupt to earn huge some from BD to move out, polluting society etc.
 
The new citizenship law isnt that bad for BD. NRC and CAA combination means population swap between BD and India. While it insures less number people will come from India but larger numbers will move out. The Hindu population is burden of BD. Them living in BD means fifth column is active inside while Indian invasion remains a threat in the name of saving them. And they choosing affairs which doesnt suit BD at all, security risks of them selling secrets of BD, humiliating BD home aborad, while most are too corrupt to earn huge some from BD to move out, polluting society etc.

If Bangladesh succeeds In the next couple of decades in military modernisation turning it into a force with real fighting power and the economy succeds, the Hindus of bd could be converted into powerful tool against India. As long as bd remains secular in coming years with Indias stupidity and bd playing their cards right we could take control of assam and west bengal.
Then India will no longer be able to bully bd.
 
If Bangladesh succeeds In the next couple of decades in military modernisation turning it into a force with real fighting power and the economy succeds, the Hindus of bd could be converted into powerful tool against India. As long as bd remains secular in coming years with Indias stupidity and bd playing their cards right we could take control of assam and west bengal.
Then India will no longer be able to bully bd.

First send BD Hindus and semi Hindu hotchpotch Muslims into India, mostly to NE. Change the demography there from Mongol to Indic. Send the Indic ones. The tribal Mongol ones of BD are asset to infiltrate into Indian NE and Arakan to assist BD. When the demography is changed in those regions. Takeover their minds and affairs through cultural infiltration, soft power, business integration etc. Without a powerful military they will on their own :coffee:
 
Or sent to Bangladesh

This is a very complex situation; not as simple, as some people think, it is. Let us suppose that a Muslim, who is living in India and claims to be an Indian citizen, is declared by the Indian government to be an illegal immigrant from BD; but BD denies this assertion; then what? That, I believe is the core issue.
 
This is a very complex situation; not as easy, as some people think, it is. Let us suppose that a Muslim, who is living in India and claims to be an Indian citizen, is declared by the government to be an illegal immigrant from BD; but BD denies this assertion; then what? That, I believe is the core issue.
Hasina has been sold out dude
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Back
Top Bottom