What's new

India cable 'authentic': Assange

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Jun 28, 2010
22,931
45
29,058
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
India Wikileaks cable is 'authentic', says Assange
Wikileaks founder Julian Assange has said the Indian PM is wrong to have doubted the veracity of a cable which has caused an uproar in India.

The diplomatic cable released by Wikileaks suggested that India's ruling Congress party bribed MPs to survive a crucial vote of confidence in 2008.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has denied the allegation and doubted the the veracity of such cables.

The leak has put pressure on Mr Singh after a string of corruption scandals.

The vote took place after the government's left-wing allies withdrew their support over a controversial nuclear deal with the United States.

But the Congress party narrowly survived the vote despite substantial opposition.

The leaked cable, reported in The Hindu newspaper, caused uproar in the Indian parliament with the main opposition parties calling on the prime minister to resign.

Mr Singh responded that no member of his Congress party or government bribed MPs ahead the vote and cast doubt on the veracity of the cable.

'Misleading'
"It is unfortunate that speculative, unverified and unverifiable communication can be given dignity by the opposition to revive old charges that have been soundly rejected," Mr Singh said.

Responding to the criticism, Mr Assange told NDTV news channel that Mr Singh's statements "seem like a deliberate attempt to mislead the public by suggesting that governments around the world do not accept the material and it is not verified".

"There is no doubt that these are bona fide reports sent by an American ambassador back to Washington, and these should be seen in that context," Mr Assange said.

"That does not mean every fact in them is correct. You have to look at their sources and how they gave this information."

If the government had lost the vote, India could have faced early elections. A defeat would have also put the nuclear deal in doubt.
BBC News - India Wikileaks cable is 'authentic', says Assange
 
Now PM should resign immediately ..!! Our Pm have taken enough Advantage of his clear image..!!!
I hope coalition party's withdraw there support from this congress immediately and Mid-term elections should be held..!

Enough of this Congress !!
 
If wikileaks concentrates on leaking just Indian diplomatic cables then they need to change their website's name from Week(i)Leaks to HourlyLeaks...............:P
 
these cable messages are just daily information feedbck , collected from media reports , gernal public opinios and talks among deplomatic community...

the messages need not be based on authentic inputs from US inteligence agents....

atleast Assange is not the right man to certified these messages as authentic...
 
these cable messages are just daily information feedbck , collected from media reports , gernal public opinios and talks among deplomatic community...

the messages need not be based on authentic inputs from US inteligence agents....

atleast Assange is not the right man to certified these messages as authentic...

You are entitled to your opinion, but Assange based his claims on confidential diplomatic cables sent by the US Ambassador, who like any other ambassador gets his information from different Agencies / Agents / Analysts, operating within his domain. Cables based on hearsay usually don't reflect very well on ones career.

Secondly," media reports, general public opinions and gossip among the diplomatic community", usually never warrants confidential cables at the ambassadorial level. A very junior officer takes care of such things.


"There is no doubt that these are bona fide reports sent by an American ambassador back to Washington, and these should be seen in that context," Mr Assange said.."
 
It surprises me how come Indian members here speak against Manmohan. He has lifted india form depths to a level where it is enjoying this ecnomic growth. Manmohan Singh is humble, down to earth and one of the most successful prime-ministers of the India so far. What makes you guys punch him? Because he doesn't have a big mouth or doesn't throw sparks out of his mouth?

Ask us how it feels to have MF Zardari as President of the country!
 
It surprises me how come Indian members here speak against Manmohan. He has lifted india form depths to a level where it is enjoying this ecnomic growth. Manmohan Singh is humble, down to earth and one of the most successful prime-ministers of the India so far. What makes you guys punch him? Because he doesn't have a big mouth or doesn't throw sparks out of his mouth?

Ask us how it feels to have MF Zardari as President of the country!


Arrey bhai..no one is saying MMS is not a gr8 person..or he is not humble or was not a gr8 FM..but he is not a leader..he is a very good bureaucrat..but not a PM material....he doesnt have the will of Indira or the charisma of Rajeev or the political cunningness of PV narsimha rao..

A PM needs more than a resume..he needs authority to rule,charisma to charm millions of followers.

To be a leader u dont need a MBA degree..u need to know how to lead..
 
Arrey bhai..no one is saying MMS is not a gr8 person..or he is not humble or was not a gr8 FM..but he is not a leader..he is a very good bureaucrat..but not a PM material....he doesnt have the will of Indira or the charisma of Rajeev or the political cunningness of PV narsimha rao..

A PM needs more than a resume..he needs authority to rule,charisma to charm millions of followers.

To be a leader u dont need a MBA degree..u need to know how to lead..

Both of you are right!! But considering the politician lot in India and Pakistan, MMS's personal character seems to be spotless, and right now with all these corrupt politicians, he is definitely a good choice.
 
It surprises me how come Indian members here speak against Manmohan. He has lifted india form depths to a level where it is enjoying this ecnomic growth. Manmohan Singh is humble, down to earth and one of the most successful prime-ministers of the India so far. What makes you guys punch him? Because he doesn't have a big mouth or doesn't throw sparks out of his mouth?

Ask us how it feels to have MF Zardari as President of the country!

he was a great FM but he is a puppet PM,he can never take decisions unilaterally
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom