What's new

Hilarious double standards ! Rahul Kanwal stumps UP Minister on Vandematram

Thank you.

Educate me how singing a song in a language an average Indian does not understand promotes public good & social well being & that too more than what it was all these decades past.


The National anthem too is an a language an average Indian does not understand. Much less remember it in total.

Yet one is required to memorize it and recite it when the occasion calls for it.

National song too holds a similar position in our Constitution and the song has a rich history of our freedom struggle behind it when it inspired Millions to fight for our freedom. The song is a reminder to us about the value of freedom and its true price.

Its also a song that reminds us of our cultural heritage and rich past. About the Social VALUES of our civilization which sustained our society and culture.

Music for this song was given my Rabindranath Tagore himself because he was inspired by this song.

As a matter of fact this song is FAR more inspiring than the rather drab "jana gana mana". Can you deny it ?



You just mentioned this song was not mandatory as per the Constitution.

Its like ' You must follow what I say, I need not".. thats what Rahul Kanwal brought out last night.

If the minister was in school, he too would have to sing it.

The minister is just correcting a mistake made in the past.

Rahul Kanwal is free to create moral outrage to push his TRP. Its the most common trick in the media play book.
 
Last edited:
As a matter of fact this song is FAR more inspiring than the rather drab "jana gana mana". Can you deny it ?

I do deny it.

However, I have no issues in singing it . My point is why was the madrasa schools only asked to sing it, record it send to Lucknow. see the debate- the answer the clot gives is that they are state funded schools so...

Why not ALL schools ?

I rest my case.
 
I do deny it.

However, I have no issues in singing it . My point is why was the madrasa schools only asked to sing it, record it send to Lucknow. see the debate- the answer the clot gives is that they are state funded schools so...

Why not ALL schools ?

That is your privilege.

I see no reason why a madrassa should be given any exceptions when other schools are not.

Are you advocating "minority appeasement" ?

For now the circular is for ALL schools including madrassa.

So what is the problem ?
 
It's lovely song but bit difficult to remember.
In school days the girl chorus used to sing it on national days and nobody remembers after that .

I love hearing it on all India radio once in a while and as write i could remember two lines of it .

It IS a lovely song.

Especially in Lata ji's voice.

Cheers, Doc
 
Hypocrisy of PM now, CM then.

Gujarat Model:

DHBQxPoXsAAx0NY.jpg


77 villages in Gujarat don't admit Dalits.
Its written outside of Temple clearly.

CM Modi did not do anything on this then, neither the PM Modi does anything now.

But yes, ambulance for cows and shoving down ethics Indian's throats
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Back
Top Bottom