What's new

Hilarious double standards ! Rahul Kanwal stumps UP Minister on Vandematram

Do you know in one meet of the BJP in 2005 when all stood to sing vande mataram none on the dias could do so . even advani ji fumbled.
 
Extreme stupidity of a minister in the UP Govt was exposed last evening on India Today TV.

This minister who had issued circulars for Vandematram to be sung in schools could not sing it himself !( Click link below)

Why are we trying to fix something thats not broken ?



http://indiatoday.intoday.in/video/vande-mataram-baldev-singh-aulakh-sakshi-maharaj/1/1024303.html

Probably because we have not been TAUGHT this National Song in SCHOOL.

And who's fault is that ?
 
Last edited:
Do you know in one meet of the BJP in 2005 when all stood to sing vande mataram none on the dias could do so . even advani ji fumbled.

Thats what I meant whan I asked why fix something thats not broke ?

Everyone is running but no one has any idea in which direction & where to .

Probably because we have not be TAUGHT this National Song in SCHOOL.

And who's fault is that ?


Its the fault of the one who does not know & yet wants to shove it down the throats of others.

The nation did not recite Vandematram, yet we won wars , stuck together & did well for 7 Decades.

Create awareness, describe the meanings ( I bet most dont even know what it means) and relevance. Let people decide.
 
Its the fault of the one who does not know & yet wants to shove it down the throats of others.

The nation did not recite Vandematram, yet we won wars , stuck together & did well for 7 Decades.

Create awareness, describe the meanings ( I bet most dont even know what it means) and relevance. Let people decide.

Since most hindus don't know Vedas, does that mean we should not teach vedas to our kids ? :cheesy:

Since most Hindus don't know Quantum Physics, we should not teach Quantum physics ?

Our nation did not have t0ilets either, and yet we won wars. So that means we do not need to build t0ilets ? :cheesy:

What kind of retarded "logic" is that ?



Teaching kids the National Song IS how you spread awareness and make it relevant. The people HAVE decided when they voted BJP to power in UP. :lol: What did you think elections were about ?
 
This is totally unnecessary humiliation of that poor minister .

I know for sure 99% indian don't remember Vande Mataram by heart . But it's totally different from someone refusing sing Vande Mataram at all .
 
What kind of retarded "logic" is that ?

Did you follow the news item where this clip came from ? I suggest you do.

Here is a minister in UP who says he issued a circular asking all Madrasas to sing Vandematram, make a video clip & send it Lucknow... I wonder why ?

Its a small thing that he himself cannot sing it to save his life.

The first principle of leadership is to lead by example ' Be the change you want to see" .. Gandhi.

Modi wants the nation to do Yoga - He does it himself , Gandhi wanted cleanliness- he cleaned toilets himself.
 
This is totally unnecessary humiliation of that poor minister .

I know for sure 99% indian don't remember Vande Mataram by heart . But it's totally different from someone refusing sing Vande Mataram at all .

Its like mocking a south Indian for not knowing Hindi :cheesy:

Or like mocking a illiterate Indian for not knowing english.


What kind of morons buy into such absurdities ? The bigots maybe.
 
That tells me we need to incorporate these songs right from childhood.
Otherwise, our children will grow up worse than these politicians.

Most BJP legislators & MP's are as good or as worse than any party ones.

Only the ones at the top are keeping a check, otherwise, all these people would be doing a Congress on us.
 
This is totally unnecessary humiliation of that poor minister .

I know for sure 99% indian don't remember Vande Mataram by heart . But it's totally different from someone refusing sing Vande Mataram at all .

I think except central school kids, including army schools, nobody even learned it.

I know its not taught in any ICSE school I know of.

Personally, I just hum along, like in Commando comics or movies when the Nazis are firing out German orders to the soldiers. And then make up with very loud chorus of Vande Mataram just to make sure.

Cheers, Doc
 
Did you follow the news item where this clip came from ? I suggest you do.

Here is a minister in UP who says he issued a circular asking all Madrasas to sing Vandematram, make a video clip & send it Lucknow... I wonder why ?

Its a small thing that he himself cannot sing it to save his life.

The first principle of leadership is to lead by example ' Be the change you want to see" .. Gandhi

LOL.... seriously ? That is your argument ?

That he is not a "true leader" because Gandhi said so ? :cheesy:

He might not be a "true leader", but he is still the Minister. And so far the CONSTITUTION of INDIA does not make it compulsory for him to know Vande Maataram if he wants to teach it to other kids.


I guess we all go by the LAW, rather than made up fake moral outrage. :lol:
 
And so far the CONSTITUTION of INDIA does not make it compulsory for him to know Vande Maataram if he wants to teach it to other kids.

If it isnt compulsory, why selectively enforce it ?

Being a minister does not make him God that he can issue diktats & not know / follow it himself.
 
If it isnt compulsory, why selectively enforce it ?

Wearing clothes is also not compulsory. Naga sadhu's walk around nude and so do Digambar jains.

Now You try walking on public roads in the nude and watch the police enforce the dress code.

Some things are enforced for public good and social well being.

Being a minister does not make him God that he can issue diktats & not know / follow it himself.

Being a minister does not make him god, but he sure as hell can issue diktats by the powers granted to him under the constitution.

There is no compulsion on him to know the song himself. Though it would be nice if he does not it, it is not a necessary condition.
 
I think except central school kids, including army schools, nobody even learned it.

I know its not taught in any ICSE school I know of.

Personally, I just hum along, like in Commando comics or movies when the Nazis are firing out German orders to the soldiers. And then make up with very loud chorus of Vande Mataram just to make sure.

Cheers, Doc

It's lovely song but bit difficult to remember.
In school days the girl chorus used to sing it on national days and nobody remembers after that .

I love hearing it on all India radio once in a while and as write i could remember two lines of it .
 
Some things are enforced for public good and social well being.

Thank you.

Educate me how singing a song in a language an average Indian does not understand promotes public good & social well being & that too more than what it was all these decades past.

Being a minister does not make him god, but he sure as hell can issue diktats by the powers granted to him under the constitution.

You just mentioned this song was not mandatory as per the Constitution.

Its like ' You must follow what I say, I need not".. thats what Rahul Kanwal brought out last night.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 2, Members: 0, Guests: 2)


Back
Top Bottom