European secularism a bad fit for India

[Saheli]

Congress runs E-NREGA not BJP.....

Now Shooooo..........

He is a primitive life form. Reasoning with him is useless.

 

[SanjeevaniButi]

1. No one is holding the present generation responsible, the reservation is meant for past acts. Perhaps you need to look up the meaning of Affirmative Action.
2. They have benefited enough from the actions of their ancestors. Either they give up those benefits or shut up about any so called burden.
3. Nope. While I have defended upper castes aplenty here, I have never heard you have anything to say good about lower castes. Nor do I advocate benefits in perpetuity unlike you who are openly biased.
4. Have you gone off your mind entirely? You mean to say India had no sense of right and wrong in ancient times? If their leaders told them to treat people as inhuman they were supposed to follow that? Do you even know the meaning of irony to make that ridiculous comparison. Have you any sense of accountability?
5. I do not know what you are talking about, you just seem to be comfortable with evil deeds and that is disgusting.
6. You do not even know what are valid arguments or what are similar situations. You make a fool of yourself when you bring in such arguments.
7. Accepting evil and being comfortable with evil is endorsing evil.
8. No, I have not worked on stereotypes but gave you what is statistical certainty. You were very happy to bring in Mayawati back then, I do not know why you should be protest over Gandhis. Oh but I know, what is good enough for others is not good enough for you.

I do not think there is any need for me to defend any personal attack. You are free to think of me as biased or being comfortable with evil.

If present generation is not responsible, then there is no need for them to pay any price. You cannot have it both ways. If they have benefited from the past then you can take away those benefits via land reforms, not deny them equal opportunity.

Either India had a sense of right and wrong and did what it had to do visa viz dalits, or India had no sense of right or wrong and did what they did. You cannot have it both way. Make up your mind.

There is no accountability for the past. Only for the present.

You have called all caste Indians corrupt, biased, exploitative and say its a statistical certainty. Which is 80% of India. I do not understand the link between Mayawati and Gandhi.