What's new

Dr Momen rubbishes Indian minister’s ridiculous comment on Bangladesh

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 3, 2015
9,641
-1
22,404
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangla...n-minister-s-ridiculous-comment-on-bangladesh

Dr Momen rubbishes Indian minister’s ridiculous comment on Bangladesh
Humayun Kabir Bhuiyan
  • Published at 11:08 pm February 10th, 2020
img-3016-1-1570649658507.jpg

File photo of Foreign Minister Dr AK Abdul Momen Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Half of Bangladesh’s populace will leave country if offered Indian citizenship, says junior Indian Home Minister

Foreign Minister Dr AK Abdul Momen rubbished the notion of the Indian State Minister for Home Affairs, who said that half of the Bangladesh’s population will leave the country if the citizenship of India is offered to Bangladeshis.

G Kishan Reddy, a right wing Hindu nationalist leader and a deputy to Indian Home Minister Amit Shah, made the ridiculous comment about Bangladesh on Sunday, report Indian media.

“I don’t want to make any comment. I really don’t know why he (the Indian minister) said what he said,” Foreign Minister Dr Momen told Dhaka Tribune on Monday when his comment was sought as regards to the remarks of Reddy.

“In most parts of our country, Bangladesh is well ahead of India in terms of all social indicators. So, why will Bangladeshis go to India?” he said.

“On the contrary, Indians badly want to come to Bangladesh,” he added.

When asked whether this type of comments from the Indian minister is helpful to the Dhaka-Delhi relationship, the Foreign Minister avoided a direct reply and advised this correspondent to stay in touch with Reddy.

However, he said, “All I can say is Bangladesh is well ahead of India.”

Despite repeated attempts, two officials concerned of the Indian High Commission in Dhaka could not be reached for comment.

“Half of the citizens of Bangladesh will leave the country if India offers citizenship to them,” Reddy was quoted as saying.

He said, “Half of Bangladesh will be empty (vacant) if India offers citizenship to them (Bangladeshis). Half of Bangladeshis will come over to India if citizenship is promised (to them). Who will take responsibility? K Chandrasekhar Rao (Telangana Chief Minister)? or Rahul Gandhi (Congress leader)?."

Reddy was speaking at a religious gathering in Hyderabad, the capital of southern India's Telangana state.

He also challenged Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrashekhar Rao, who appealed to Prime Minister Narendra Modi to rethink on the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) law, asking him to prove in what way the CAA was against the people living in India.

"They seek citizenship for infiltrators. Indian government is ready to review the CAA if it has one word against anyone of the 1.3 billion citizens, but not for Pakistani or Bangladeshi Muslims," he said.

The Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and the National Citizens’ Register (NRC) were a key part of the election manifesto of Modi's ruling Hindu nationalist party.

Indian government believes the legislation is needed to protect refugees across south Asia. The CAA aims to fast-track citizenship for persecuted Hindus, Parsis, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains and Christians who arrived in India before December 31, 2014, from Muslim-majority Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan.

Clashes between protesters and police leaving at least 25 dead have been a regular occurrence since December 12, when the government passed the legislation.

Tens of thousands protested in India’s financial hub of Mumbai, as well as Lucknow, the capital of populous Uttar Pradesh state which has seen the highest number of deaths since the unrest began. Both were predominantly female-led.
 
https://thewire.in/external-affairs/g-kishan-reddy-bangladesh-india
EXTERNAL AFFAIRS
Junior Home Minister's Remarks on Bangladesh Could Impact Bilateral Ties, Say Former Envoys
The envoys said that the comments were in poor taste and ill informed.

Screen-Shot-2019-10-05-at-6.14.13-PM.png

Prime minister Narendra Modi and his Bangladesh counterpart Sheikh Hasina. Photo: Twitter/@MEAIndia

wire-logo.png

The Wire Staff
DIPLOMACY
EXTERNAL AFFAIRS
SOUTH ASIA
12 HOURS AGO

New Delhi: A statement by Minister of State of Home Affairs G. Kishan Reddy has again raised concerns that there is a lack of sensitivity among the larger political establishment about the impact of remarks on Bangladesh prime minister Sheikh Hasina’s domestic political capital and therefore on bilateral relations with India.

On Sunday, PTI had reported that Reddy criticised Telangana chief minister K. Chandrasekhar Rao for opposing the Citizenship Amendment Act, claiming that expanding provisions to Muslims in Bangladesh would lead to over half of the south Asian neighbour’s population to enter India.

“Half of Bangladesh will be empty (vacant) if India offers citizenship to them (Bangladeshis). Half of Bangladeshis will come over to India if citizenship is promised (to them). Who will take responsibility? KCR? Or Rahul Gandhi?” he had asked.

“They seek citizenship for infiltrators. The government of India is ready to review the CAA if it has one word against anyone of the 130 crore citizens, but not for Pakistani or Bangladeshi Muslims,” Reddy had also said.

There has been no official response from the Bangladesh government, even as Bangladeshi media did take note of these remarks. Dhaka Tribune termed it a “ridiculous” comment.

Also read: Dilip Ghosh Now Promises to ‘Send Back 1 Crore Illegal Bangladeshis’

Relations between India and Bangladesh have come under a shadow in recent months especially following the passage of the Citizenship Amendment Act. The legislation allows for fast track citizenship for six non-Muslim and non-Jewish religious minorities from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan on grounds that they have been prosecuted.

Speaking to The Wire, former Indian high commissioner to Bangladesh Deb Mukherjee said that Dhaka was likely to view these remarks with “distaste and contempt”.

“These are bizarre statements,” he said.

However, Mukherjee stated that the silence from Dhaka to such repeated statements from BJP leaders. “Whether it is the mention of “termites” or that “Bangladesh will become vacant,” these are in such poor taste and so ill-informed…what will the Bangladesh government actually say about them?” he said.

Even while the Bangladesh government is silent, Mukherjee said that he feels that there will be a cumulative impact on Bangladesh-India relations. “Of course, they will have an impact on Bangladeshis, as it shows that India as an unreliable and arrogant partner”.

The retired Indian foreign service officer said that the statements show India to be “unreliable”, as they demonstrate that Indian ministers are not looking at “political repercussions for (prime minister) Sheikh Hasina back home”. Mukherjee was referring to the popular perception that Hasina has been more friendly towards India, compared to the political opposition in Bangladesh when they were in power.

“How will the PM face up to the people?”

Another former Indian high commissioner to Bangladesh, who did not want to be named, felt that that Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s assurance that the National Register of Citizens and CAA will not impact Bangladesh may have played in Dhaka’s calculations in remaining silent.

Also read: CAA an Internal Matter, But Don’t Understand Why India Did it: Bangladesh PM

After Sheikh Hasina met with Modi on the sidelines of United Nations General Assembly in New York, in September 2019, Bangladeshi media had reported that the Indian leader had given assurance that NRC won’t impact Dhaka after the former noted that it was of “great concern”.

The former Indian envoy told The Wire that his contacts in Dhaka have expressed concern that repeated statements about Bangladeshis “vitiate the atmosphere” and create a sense of “distrust”.

He noted that the main concern in Dhaka was that the CAA, coupled with the NRC, could lead to a large movement of people without the requisite documentation, towards Bangladesh.

Former Bangladesh high commissioner to India Tariq Karim described the remarks by Reddy as “outrageous and incendiary. “(This is) not the way to win friends or influence people. People are incensed by these insulting remarks,” Karim, who had been Dhaka’s envoy to India for over five years till 2015, told The Wire.

Following the passage of CAA in early December 2019, Bangladesh foreign minister A.K. Abdul Momen cancelled his trip to Delhi, just 24 hours before his arrival. Both India and Bangladesh maintained that the visit had been postponed as Momen had to take part in two important national events.

Following Amit Shah’s initial remarks in Lok Sabha while steering the legislation, the Indian government had to clarify that he had only been referring to atrocities against minorities under the previous government run by the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP).

Indian officials had argued that relations haven not deteriorated as portrayed in the media, pointing out that there had been a meeting of security personnel and trade officials.

Last month, Bangladesh junior foreign minister M. Shahriar Alam had cancelled his participation in the Raisina Dialogue. However, Bangladeshi information minister Hasan Mahmud came to Delhi on schedule for a meeting with his Indian counterpart and met with the Prime Minister too.

Modi is scheduled to visit Dhaka next month to take part in founder of Bangladesh, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s birth centenary celebrations.
 
Shri Momen ubacho ( momen said),

Where ever you go whatever you do, I will no longer be right here waiting for you my beloved spouse!
:rofl::rofl::rofl:
 
They have got a big slap today at Delhi vote!
However, Congress is in more dire condition without a single seat. AAP is the sole beneficiary of voting against the corrupt BJP.

Modi is scheduled to visit Dhaka next month to take part in founder of Bangladesh, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s birth centenary celebrations.
People should throw shoes at Modi in Dhaka for his anti-Muslim rhetorics.
 
However, Congress is in more dire condition without a single seat. AAP is the sole beneficiary of voting against the corrupt BJP.


People should throw shoes at Modi in Dhaka for his anti-Muslim rhetorics.

This vote is direct slap to BJP and Amit Shah. Who ran an anti Muslim campaign in this election.

Threaten to drive out the Muslim, change name of Shahin bug to Shanti bug, taking measure against Muslim, making comments on Bangladesh, so on and on!
 
Muslims should rise against and demand two Azad lands, one in India's east and the other in the west. The way India is run by the BJP amateurs, someday a movement will start. BJP thinks a country is like a circus party. BJP guys are playing clowns in a circus.

Politicians in power should unite the divided population and BJP is doing just the opposite while the GDP growth was stuck at 3.5% growth in the 3rd quarter of 2019 FY.
 
People should throw shoes at Modi in Dhaka for his anti-Muslim rhetorics.
People should not do it. If they do, it will send a bad message to international community. We take action in other ways, not by throwing shoes to anyone, even if it's the butcher Modi. After all he will be our guest when he will be visiting Bangladesh. I don't support it because I am not a fan of democracy.

We can't do whatever we wish. We must do something that will benefit us. Does our govt have the ball to prevent the visit of Modi? Why did they invite the butcher to celebrate? It's totally the fault of our govt.

Muslims should rise against and demand two Azad lands, one in India's east and the other in the west.
Indian Muslims lack the ball. They lack the balls and that's why in 1947 they stayed in India. If they willingly left India, Muslim nation would got more land.
 
“I don’t want to make any comment. I really don’t know why he (the Indian minister) said what he said,” Foreign Minister Dr Momen told Dhaka Tribune on Monday when his comment was sought as regards to the remarks of Reddy.

I think the Bangali dude is an idiot if he still doesn't know why the Hindutva made that comment....

If you don't know what India of today is.... You need to get your head examined,.... unless he's playing dumb.

Jai Hind! Jai Shri Ram Ram! Jai rape and lynchings!
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 2, Members: 0, Guests: 2)


Back
Top Bottom