What's new

Distinction for India at Afghanistan meet

India is the only country with a security pact with Afghanistan.

India has invsetd heavily in Afghanistan and shown committment.

India has a potentially useful Iran road link for landlocked Afghanistan.

India generally has a favorable image in the people of Afghanistan.

India will be training tens of thousands of Afghan troops in India and Afghanistan. Nato, Russia, Iran, CAR comfortable with that.

And this gentleman like a mindless zombie keeps asking what value you have and this and that and blah blah blah blah blah blah blah...

Seriously, needs a life. Easier to educate a rock.
 
You have quite clearly avoided the questions I posed on my post, bravo.

The major value it would have in this conference of being a backup of US/NATO after it's withdrawal to civilian and military leadership, huge welfare investments are taking place by India in Afghanistan which worth $11 bln+, India may increase it's donation (which is $2bln) in this conference, India is the first country who signed strategic partnership with us and is attending this conference last but not least absence of Pakistan would have a value to India in conference.

But still as I said before wait for some more days the real thing will come up.
 
India is the only country with a security pact with Afghanistan.

US & the NATO Forces have invested a lot more in security for Afghanistan.

India has invsetd heavily in Afghanistan and shown committment.

US has shown a commitment for over 10 years, & spent $110 billion per year in Afghanistan, along with $4 billion per year on civilian aid. I'm sure India can do better than that.

India generally has a favorable image in the people of Afghanistan.

The Indians are completely alien in the eyes of the Afghans, so India is a non-matter for them.

India will be training tens of thousands of Afghan troops in India and Afghanistan.

The US & NATO Forces have been training a lot more Afghan troops in Afghanistan, I'm sure India can do a better job than the US & the NATO Forces combined together.
 
US & the NATO Forces have invested a lot more in security for Afghanistan.



US has shown a commitment for over 10 years, & spent $110 billion per year in Afghanistan, along with $4 billion per year on civilian aid. I'm sure India can do better than that.



The Indians are completely alien in the eyes of the Afghans, so India is a non-matter for them.



The US & NATO Forces have been training a lot more Afghan troops in Afghanistan, I'm sure India can do a better job than the US & the NATO Forces combined together.


Are you confused or willing to confuse us? It regards to Afghanistan and India where does US/NATO comes between them? If you are comparing India with US/NATO that's what I also agree even the Indians too that US is superior than India. But why are you wasting your time on this?
 
Are you confused or willing to confuse us? It regards to Afghanistan and India where does US/NATO comes between them? If you are comparing India with US/NATO that's what I also agree even the Indians too that US is superior than India. But why are you wasting your time on this?

Because US military cables have said Afghanistan will go to a civil war once Western troops leave the region. So India has little significance in this regard, except the proxy war it will use Afghanistan for.
 
From that $4bln aid per year by USA, Afghan government is only allowed to spend 20% of the money by it's own that's why all these aids are wasted by US themselves and part of that 20% always go to some corrupt people. But whatever aid/trade is coming from India we have all control upon it which will be competitively more fruitful than US's aid.
 
Funny, the Hindustanis constantly write good-feel stories about themselves. I wasn't surprised to find out the source was "thehindu.com". Typical Hindustanis write their own story lines to create their own story.
 
Funny, the Hindustanis constantly write good-feel stories about themselves. I wasn't surprised to find out the source was "thehindu.com". Typical Hindustanis write their own story lines to create their own story.

hindu is one of the best paper in world and if you cant digest it then blame the paper.FYI,this paper is mostly anti india
 
You have just clearly avoided my question.

Maybe instead of having hate for the nation that has held 5 million refugees of your country, paid for them, a nation that supplies your food & other basic necessities, as well as your biggest exporting (opium & other things) & importing nation, you should learn to show a little bit of respect, instead of letting your country be used as proxy land against Pakistan by foreign powers. These are the words your president, a Pakistan hater who has said about Pakistan:

India 'close friend' but Pak 'conjoined twin', says Afghanistan - Times Of India

We don't want proxy wars in Afghanistan, Karzai says | Reuters

Afghanistan to back Pakistan if wars with U.S.: Karzai | Reuters
 
Americas goals in Afghanistan is different than Indias goal in Afghanistan
USAs goal was neutralizing taliban which they have successfully done to an extent

No they haven't, instead the taliban have gained more momentum, the only time taliban were at their weakest was from 2001-2005.


, Indias goal is stable friendly Afghanistan...

Who do you think your kidding? indans can care less about the ordinary Afghan since india shares no border with Afghanistan, indians just want to foment problems between Afghanistan and Pakistan in order to sandwich Pakistan.

US would not even have worried whats happening in Afghanistan until 9/11 happened and Taliban refused to hand over OBL ... the rest is history ... bottom line is USA wanted to eliminate taliban from Afghan ,which essentially meant a military aggressive position ... and more over many Afghans see USA/NATO as occupying force but no such worries for India .More money is not what Afghanistan needs , basic needs like food , shelter, roads and electricity .. India surely can help them with that ... India hgas sent lot of wheat , clothing too in the past and these kind of gestures have won over Afghan peoples goodwill for India

india has done very little compared to what Pakistan or the US had given to Afghanistan, indians boast about the wheat and cloths they gave to Afghanistan but that is nothing in comparison to what Pakistan has been doing for Afghanistan for the past 3 decades. Once NATO pulls out, will india take the burden of donating billions, even trillions of $ to keep the Afghan government and ANA from falling apart? I think indians can say good bye to their growing economy then.
 
Maybe instead of having hate for the nation that has held 5 million refugees of your country, paid for them, a nation that supplies your food & other basic necessities, as well as your biggest exporting (opium & other things) & importing nation, you should learn to show a little bit of respect, instead of letting your country be used as proxy land against Pakistan by foreign powers. These are the words your president, a Pakistan hater who has said about Pakistan:

India 'close friend' but Pak 'conjoined twin', says Afghanistan - Times Of India

We don't want proxy wars in Afghanistan, Karzai says | Reuters

Afghanistan to back Pakistan if wars with U.S.: Karzai | Reuters

Brother I don't know why you guys just directly go to all these things, we really admire every thing from the people of Pakistan they are religiously, culturally, linguistically our brothers but we are repeatedly saying that we have problem with your so-called 'strategic depth' in Afghanistan which has badly harmed the innocent civilians and the system.
 
Brother I don't know why you guys just directly go to all these things, we really admire every thing from the people of Pakistan they are religiously, culturally, linguistically our brothers but we are repeatedly saying that we have problem with your so-called 'strategic depth' in Afghanistan which has badly harmed the innocent civilians and the system.

Don't give me BS, you don't admire anything, you are an ungrateful, hypocritical brat, your country sent troops into Bajaur in 1960, to coax the tribals in making them revolt against Pakistan for "Pashtunistan". Neither the Pashtun leaders, nor the non-Pashtun leaders in power in Afghanistan have accepted the validity of the Durand Line. You have let your country be used willingly as proxy land for foreign powers against Pakistan.

A very interesting phenomena is found in many Afghan people. They want to distinguish between the Mujahideen in the 80s & the Taliban. When they consider the Mujahideen's cause in the 80s to be just, they praise the US for its efforts in the region (even though they abandoned after they left Afghanistan after breaking up the Soviet Union). When I point to them that the Mujahideen has many of the same leaders the US is fighting today (Mullah Omar, OBL, Haqqanis, Hekmetyar & others); they blame Pakistan for its role in the 80s (even though the Mujahideen were made up of primarily Afghan fighters) in training the Mujahideen.

Neither the US nor Pakistan (or anyone else) is responsible for Afghanistan, only the Afghans are. Stop blaming us for your problems, & learn to take responsibility for your own issues.
 
Don't give me BS, you don't admire anything, you are an ungrateful, hypocritical brat, your country sent troops into Bajaur in 1960, to coax the tribals in making them revolt against Pakistan for "Pashtunistan". Neither the Pashtun leaders, nor the non-Pashtun leaders in power in Afghanistan have accepted the validity of the Durand Line. You have let your country be used willingly as proxy land for foreign powers against Pakistan.

Well, when everything related to 2001-2011 is once answered to you guys than you guys put your reverse gear and go back to some 4 or 5 decade's old stories. It's just not me but all Afghans think once they get the durand line than they will not have to say thanks to anyone for anything.

A very interesting phenomena is found in many Afghan people. They want to distinguish between the Mujahideen in the 80s & the Taliban. When they consider the Mujahideen's cause in the 80s to be just, they praise the US for its efforts in the region (even though they abandoned after they left Afghanistan after breaking up the Soviet Union). When I point to them that the Mujahideen has many of the same leaders the US is fighting today (Mullah Omar, OBL, Haqqanis, Hekmetyar & others); they blame Pakistan for its role in the 80s (even though the Mujahideen were made up of primarily Afghan fighters).

Whatever it is but directly or indirectly you guys played out for you interests in Afghanistan leaving to think that such interests may become no-interest in a long run.

Neither the US nor Pakistan (or anyone else) is responsible for Afghanistan, only the Afghans are. Stop blaming us for your problems, & learn to take responsibility for your own issues.

We are just doing that.
 
Don't give me BS, you don't admire anything, you are an ungrateful, hypocritical brat, your country sent troops into Bajaur in 1960, to coax the tribals in making them revolt against Pakistan for "Pashtunistan". Neither the Pashtun leaders, nor the non-Pashtun leaders in power in Afghanistan have accepted the validity of the Durand Line. You have let your country be used willingly as proxy land for foreign powers against Pakistan.

A very interesting phenomena is found in many Afghan people. They want to distinguish between the Mujahideen in the 80s & the Taliban. When they consider the Mujahideen's cause in the 80s to be just, they praise the US for its efforts in the region (even though they abandoned after they left Afghanistan after breaking up the Soviet Union). When I point to them that the Mujahideen has many of the same leaders the US is fighting today (Mullah Omar, OBL, Haqqanis, Hekmetyar & others); they blame Pakistan for its role in the 80s (even though the Mujahideen were made up of primarily Afghan fighters).

Neither the US nor Pakistan (or anyone else) is responsible for Afghanistan, only the Afghans are. Stop blaming us for your problems, & learn to take responsibility for your own issues.

More ungrateful Afghans and their love of Bharat (aka india)

The problem is, these Afghans are ungrateful, they cross into Pakistan from their stone age country, eat, sleep, work, raise families and businesses in Pakistan, and then support india, how brotherly of them.

I think it is high time we kidnap every damn Afghan from every corner of Pakistan, all 5 million+ of them, seize their assets, and pack them into trains and trucks, and send them into india via Wagah border, it will save us a whole lot of space, money, and most of all solve our terrorists problem, on the other hand those indians can enjoy their romantic love affair with the Afghans by witnessing a new 26/11 every day.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom