Did the Saudis win or lose in Yemen?

[Yongpeng Sun-Tastaufen]

They failed their primary objective. Capture Sanaa and return their Yemen president Hadi back to power. Hadi is going on 74 and won't live for much longer. There will be constitutional crisis in Yemen when Hadi dies in Saudi Arabia.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

For now, it's a definite stalemate

 

[The SC]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.al...ael-collaborating-in-joint-intelligence-force



I thought it was common knowledge...hence I found it odd that any itemised list of KSA's coalition against Houthis/Iranian proxies wouldn't make mention of Israel. If Israel was assisting Pak against India in any way whatsoever, I would proudly state that this was the case - they are after all a powerful ally.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.jpos...icated-spy-systems-to-Saudi-Arabia-570539/amp

They are allies of the US with whom KSA is Ally too.. how can you be proud of a declared enemy?

 

[Arsalan 345]

Don't avert the question. Just answer me, name one single Iranian commander killed in Yemen.

About Israeli strikes in Syria, only in two attacks Iranian nationals have been killed, both of which announced by Iran openly. one in 2015 and one in 2018. The former was answered by targeting Israeli convoy and killing two IDF soldiers and injuring more, the latter answered by firing dozens of rockets into occupied Golan heights.

you are fighting a proxy.your soldiers will not move to other bases without proper orders and in proxy war,you don't name commanders and soldiers.you know this.i am not fool.i know tactics as well.

 

[raptor22]

"...It was later revealed that this well-planned attack against the Kingdom was orchestrated many years ago. The parties conspiring against Saudi Arabia were just waiting for a conflict or an internal war to send thousands of mercenaries to storm the border and occupy Saudi cities...."
​

When exactly it was revealed? Even american intelligence sources rejected the notion that Iran was behind it & it's well documented that Iran did not seek escalation of the situation besides Iran endless efforts to have ceasefire at the beginning of the war proves how writer has no clue about the war he is talking about ..the article is in denial of many factors in a way that even don't mention them & in a stupid attempt tries to portray the sole reason behind of war "occupation of Saudi's lands" even if it was Saudis whom invaded ... but indeed Saudi are victorious & this 6 months old article proves it even though none of their main objectives have been achieved ..

 

[skyshadow]

Iran will not let war in Yemen ends that simply Iran want Yemen to be strong and pro_Iran and it wants Saudi Arabia busy so they loss money and power every day a free Saudi Arabia is bad for Iran plans if it wants to be superpower of the middle east and these wars will not stop unless one party ( Iran or Saudi Arabia ) give up and other one become power house in ME. this is the reality and there is no way around it.

 

[Hack-Hook]

i think they killed lots of irani commanders in yemen just like israel is hammering iran in syria but saudis are killing civilians in large numbers.basically you have two brutal regimes.one who doesn't care about anyone but care about oil and other who dream about greater persia but are coward.both using proxies but iran is totally out of control and needs treatment.

You need iranian are like aliens if you kill them they will evaporate and there won't be any remain of them to show to the world.

No sir if there be any iranian martyr you can be sure there will be such funeral for him.

hahaha are you kidding me? i heard two days ago that your soldiers died during israel attack on syria.if you are strong,attack israel.why always giving threats to pakistan? do you really think that pakistan considers iran a threat? lol

Care to show their bodies or name them or maybe you too also believe Iranian soldiers will evaporate after martyrdom. as far as I'm aware Israel is extra careful only attack syrian in syria

 

[Bahram Esfandiari]

The only people Saudis can beat are there poor slave laborers and their wives of course!

 

[Arsalan 345]

You need iranian are like aliens if you kill them they will evaporate and there won't be any remain of them to show to the world.

No sir if there be any iranian martyr you can be sure there will be such funeral for him.

Care to show their bodies or name them or maybe you too also believe Iranian soldiers will evaporate after martyrdom. as far as I'm aware Israel is extra careful only attack syrian in syria

Only cia can provide accurate numbers of Irani soldiers in Syria.i am not cia but in proxy war,you basically hide identity of soldiers.it's common practice.

 

[925boy]

hahaha are you kidding me? i heard two days ago that your soldiers died during israel attack on syria.if you are strong,attack israel.why always giving threats to pakistan? do you really think that pakistan considers iran a threat? lol



see this.now this is clearly your enemy.

Instead of providing evidence for your claim, you start side tracking with irrelevant information. You're posts are sometimes unstable. You got owned this time tho. cheers.

Bro

On many occasions Israel has attacked Iranians and their assets...isn’t it time that you guys unleashed some lethal weapons to show Israel that you guys are not paper tigers?

1) Since Israel has big supporters like US, Iran cannot directly attack Israel for no reason. That could bring serious destruction of Iran.
2) Why dont you Sunni Muslims from Pakistan and GCC just mind your business since you've all sold Palestine to Israel already for nothing? Gaza can only fight back now mostly due to Iranian help. You guys sold rest of world hot air talk and you look like hypocrites- you have no anti Israel credentials worth boasting about, so what gives you the authority to question another country that has done alot more than yours has?

 

[Imran Khan]

well i think its not worth to fight with Yemen they were already destroyed 4th world country . total failed since ages . while Saudi is developed country . we can not imagine some years ago that someone will fire missiles on KSA . It should be secret war from day one intelligence operations rather then open war . the money KSA spent bombing Yemen you can buy 3 Yemen like countries .

 

[925boy]

For now, it's a definite stalemate

a govt with trillions of dollars of national wealth + billions of dollars of US military equipment in a stalemate vs militia in the poorest arab country = loss for Saudi Arabia. If you stalemate against a much weaker power, they've won...you've just not accepted it formally yet.

 

[Imran Khan]

a govt with trillions of dollars or national wealth + billions of dollars of US military equipment in a stalemate vs militia in the poorest arab country = loss for Saudi Arabia. If you stalemate against a much weaker power, they've won...you've just not accepted it formally yet.

if Saudi pay 1bn$ to houthis they were today bombing Iran just look these drug users houthis you can buy 16 of them in 5 dollars

 

[925boy]

you are fighting a proxy.your soldiers will not move to other bases without proper orders and in proxy war,you don't name commanders and soldiers.you know this.i am not fool.i know tactics as well.

False. when will you stop lying? you state too much BS in your posts.

Iranian commanders i can remember who died in proxy wars:
Hamdani- died in Iraq while organizing Iraqi militias to stave off ISIS
Heidar Ismail OR Ismail Kowsar?- Dont remember his name well but he was oNe of the first Iranian commanders to die in Syria. I watched a video about him and what he did in SYria.

So some IRanian commanders who died in proxy theaters have been mentioned and eulogized. Now where you get YOUR BS military info , i have no idea.

Iran will not let war in Yemen ends that simply Iran want Yemen to be strong and pro_Iran and it wants Saudi Arabia busy so they loss money and power every day a free Saudi Arabia is bad for Iran plans if it wants to be superpower of the middle east and these wars will not stop unless one party ( Iran or Saudi Arabia ) give up and other one become power house in ME. this is the reality and there is no way around it.

I agree with you- Saudis allowed Iran gets its cheapest and most effective chance(Yemen war) to bogg down Saudis.

Now instead of fat, stupid, incompetent and delusional Saudis to send 20K ground forces into Yemen and finish the war of, they havent, so are getting drained slowly and surely. As more time passes, the more the Houthis leverage in a negotiation about the Yemen war.

 

[raptor22]

if Saudi pay 1bn$ to houthis they were today bombing Iran just look these drug users houthis you can buy 16 of them in 5 dollars

Then tell Saudis to pay money that end the war ...