What's new

Day after Ram Navami, locals step in to defuse ‘tension’ in Kolkata’s Port area

Dear indian,

I was not aware that Mr. @The_Showstopper was a minority religion person. Regardless, he has been courteous and civil. He brought in historic references and information that was unkonwn to me.

This seems to be a blatant lie. @The_Showstopper has never hidden the fact that he is a Muslim. You are not a new member. If you have interactions with him or even seen his previous posts you would have known about his religion. And I am sure you are aware of him as you say

Hence, I hold his views and feedbacks in high esteem. Furthermore, he is one or two of the people here at PDF from india who is against fascist forces.

So to say you are unaware of his religion is disenginuous at best

It is disturbing to see that you will see Mr. @The_Showstopper through the hue of his religion or race first than as your own countryman first.

Do you think all Indians will have correct knowledge of Hinduism? Are all Indians hindus?

You are asking questions about Hinduism Not India. So it is better to ask a Hindu rather than a non Hindu Indian
 
This seems to be a blatant lie. @The_Showstopper has never hidden the fact that he is a Muslim. You are not a new member. If you have interactions with him or even seen his previous posts you would have known about his religion. And I am sure you are aware of him as you say

So to say you are unaware of his religion is disenginuous at best

Do you think all Indians will have correct knowledge of Hinduism? Are all Indians hindus?

You are asking questions about Hinduism Not India. So it is better to ask a Hindu rather than a non Hindu Indian

He is just playing mind games , psy ops and trolling. As you can see from this thread, no one has taken his rant seriously. :P (except the LTTE brigade)
 
This seems to be a blatant lie. @The_Showstopper has never hidden the fact that he is a Muslim. You are not a new member. If you have interactions with him or even seen his previous posts you would have known about his religion. And I am sure you are aware of him as you say



So to say you are unaware of his religion is disenginuous at best



Do you think all Indians will have correct knowledge of Hinduism? Are all Indians hindus?

You are asking questions about Hinduism Not India. So it is better to ask a Hindu rather than a non Hindu Indian
Why are you getting so riled up? He might have not noticed me or my posts. I haven't noticed him posting his views in many of the threads I started previously until recently. So calm down.

Dude if Hindus can speak about Islam and muslim personal laws on both on internet and on other media, you shouldn't get offended either if a non-Hindu speaks on Hinduism. You can present your views but you can't stop me or other non-Hindu from speaking about Hinduism, Our country's constitution grants us that right.
 
Why are you getting so riled up? He might have not noticed me or my posts. I haven't noticed him posting his views in many of the threads I started previously until recently. So calm down.

Dude if Hindus can speak about Islam and muslim personal laws on both on internet and on other media, you shouldn't get offended either if a non-Hindu speaks on Hinduism. You can present your views but you can't stop me or other non-Hindu from speaking about Hinduism, Our country's constitution grants us that right.
I am NOT saying that you cant speak and give your views on Hinduism

I was merely pointing out the fact that if you want to know something about Hinduism it is better to ask Hindus as compared to Muslims
 
I am NOT saying that you cant speak and give your views on Hinduism

I was merely pointing out the fact that if you want to know something about Hinduism it is better to ask Hindus as compared to Muslims

You have to give him credit for bad mouthing India and Indians to chinese and rest of the world. That is what passes for "patriots" with the owasis of the world :lol:
 
India has the highest number of Mosques in the World.

3 Lakh Mosques.

No other muslim nation has this many mosques. Yet the Hindu is Communal.

There are 24 churchs in Washington,
71 Church in london
69 church in Milan, Italy
But Delhi has 271 Churches, and yet the Hindu is communal.

I have seen Hindus hold Iftar parties, but has never seen a muslim hold a Diwali or Holi party and yet the Hindu is Communal.


I have seen kashmiri muslims burn Indian flag, but has never seen them burn a pakistani flag, and yet the Hindu is Communal.


I have seen Hindus wearing a muslim skull cap and visiting mosques, but have never seen a muslim were a Tilak OR VIsit a Temple, yet the Hindu is communal.


Its only Fair that Hindus in Bengal deserve a Mamata Banerjee to piss all over them.

Those comments are highly general and without basis. I suggest your retract them. No amount of crying will turn Kolkata or WB folks as communal Hindu or Muslim fanatics - they are too educated/secular for that.

And there is no 'faida' in painting Muslims and Hindus with too broad a brush and type-casting them.

I own several Fatuas, Gairic/Namavali clothing, Dhotis gifted by some Hindu friends and I have gone to temples on Saraswati Pujas and been to several Holis and Ras-Gharvas. And dare I say - I enjoyed the experience. Is that supposed to prevent me from practicing my relationship with Allah or make me less of a Muslim? And knowing some of my Muslim friends - they are in my space too.

I think we should all stop pigeon-holing and labeling people......causes nothing but trouble.
 
Those comments are highly general and without basis. I suggest your retract them. No amount of crying will turn Kolkata or WB folks as Hindu or Muslim fanatics - they are too educated/secular for that.

And there is no 'faida' in painting Muslims and Hindus with too broad a brush and type-casting them.

I own several Fatuas, Gairic/Namavali clothing, Dhotis gifted by some Hindu friends and I have gone to temples and been to several Holis and Ras-Gharvas. Is that supposed to prevent me from practicing my relationship with Allah? And knowing some of my Muslim friends - they are in my space too.

I think we should all stop pigeon-holing and labeling people......causes nothing but trouble.

Do you know that muslims in Kolkata have to change their names to Hindu names to find job as a maid in a hindu household ?

Does that sound secular to you ?

Its funny that you say that "we" should all stop pigeon holing and labeling people.

Do you know who started with these labels ? "KAFIR", "DHIMMI", "MUSHRIK", "ABEED" etc..

Why don't you practice what you preach by striking out these words from the quran ?
 
Do you know that muslims in Kolkata have to change their names to Hindu names to find job as a maid in a hindu household ?

Does that sound secular to you ?

Its funny that you say that "we" should all stop pigeon holing and labeling people.

Do you know who started with these labels ? "KAFIR", "DHIMMI", "MUSHRIK", "ABEED" etc..

Why don't you practice what you preach by striking out these words from the quran ?

Almost no one in Dhaka uses those words for non-Muslims unless it's an uneducated extremist (0.00001% of the population). And talking to Kolkata Muslims, I haven't gotten the feeling that such a thing exists in Kolkata either. You are clutching at straws here.

These sound like these are straight out of the standard RSS youth wing propaganda booklet.

Some people will try to whip up communalism to further their own interests - but educated people are too smart for them.
 
Almost no one in Dhaka uses those words for non-Muslims unless it's an uneducated extremist (0.00001% of the population). And talking to Kolkata Muslims, I haven't gotten the feeling that such a thing exists in Kolkata either. You are clutching at straws here.

These sound like these are straight out of the standard RSS youth wing propaganda booklet.

Some people will try to whip up communalism to further their own interests - but educated people are too smart for them.

Denial is not just a river in Egypt. How does Aljazeera sound ? Washington post ?

http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/fe...as-hindus-india-jobs-2013129134443863250.html

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2007/aug/21/indias-muslims-adopt-hindu-names/


Since you wanted a withdrawal of a post using "labels", the right thing to do would be to withdraw the quran with such labels.

Otherwise what moral right do you have to make such a demand ? First practice what you preach.
 
By the way - we made a 'Kafir' one of our top models (Vidya Sinha Saha),
14717157_1466558860042970_3524660387271734636_n.jpg


And here is one of our top 'Mushrik' cricket stars (Soumya).
215809-768x537.jpg


Some communalism - huh?
 
This seems to be a blatant lie. @The_Showstopper has never hidden the fact that he is a Muslim. You are not a new member. If you have interactions with him or even seen his previous posts you would have known about his religion. And I am sure you are aware of him as you say



So to say you are unaware of his religion is disenginuous at best



Do you think all Indians will have correct knowledge of Hinduism? Are all Indians hindus?

You are asking questions about Hinduism Not India. So it is better to ask a Hindu rather than a non Hindu Indian




Dear indian,


Your assualt is understandable, yet construct of your arguement is impotent.

One requires none of clarification or justification for anything here... least of all to you, dear indian.

My interest in your dialectics of Will to Power was excited by this StraightShooter person...with his claims of pending destruction of 1000s of places of worship of your resident / captive minorities...
This quite an amazing idea...Of course, you would support your countrymen on this. Understanable....totally.

Also, we outside observers always held this belief that Mr. Jinnah of Pak was the one who proposed partition of British colony on religious lines... here Mr. @The_Showstopper proivded an indepth historic reference.... hence the esteem and interest for the kind gentleman. Did not know his faithsystem...and frankly, why would it matter?

Is he an indian or not? That is the question



When you and yours come in flying high on lame wooden horses... decency and decorum requires distance for obvious reasons... hence studied avoidance of certain types of you.

We, outsiders, are just bemused observers of your Dialectic Acceleration... by trying to curtail engagment with your own countrymen of different convictions you obviously validate what is so 'blatant'. Can you even SEE it?


You are free to make fun of us and naturally, hurl massive abuse on us in your own fora...call us all things as you wish. However, here at PDF, we are allowed to engage your minorities as well. They aer NOT Untouchable here.


A discourse of mutual respect and advancement of our understanding is welcome.... for that you need to excercise certain manners.

We all wish you the very best in your pursuit of Supermacy and Accquisition of Lost Glories.
All the bands, banners and marches, onwards, onwards to the Great indian empire...you keep marching.


Regards,

SPF

@The Eagle @waz @Oscar gentlemen, are we are allowed to engage indian minorities to help shape our understanding of things indian or do we have to go throgh the Gatekeeprs of R-SS Purity Port?

As guests here we all would like to keep your good PDF a nice place that it is.
Kindly, do indulge us with your guidance. Thanks as always!
 
I am NOT saying that you cant speak and give your views on Hinduism

I was merely pointing out the fact that if you want to know something about Hinduism it is better to ask Hindus as compared to Muslims
But your previous post didn't indicate the same, hence my reply.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Back
Top Bottom