BNP hartal a demo of despicable politics: Indian daily

[Spring Onion]

if writing abt a neighbouring country is equivalent to poking nose into their internal matter, then in PDF we talk of - nay we literally rip apart - so many nation's defence/politics even history and geography. if you dont like his comments, you express your opinion. the news paper has not forced anyone to read it, like the textbooks being cooked up, neither has it created any furore in BD.

BD is much more mature than to react to an editorial of a newspaper of their own country - let alone other countries!

You can write about politics, defence even criticise policies of your neighbours about human rights issues BUT you can not take sides of certain political party over INTERNAL issues of a country other than your owns.

Its like if Pakistan or BD media starts dictating Indians NOT to protest over rising inflation in India and further dictate you that since its due to global economic trend so BJP should not hold protest over this issue. How will you take it ? do we have right to dictate you like that over your purely internal issue???

 

[Spring Onion]

Sleeping. Sue them if you want to.

But I'm more concerned about the fact that you don't care whether people are injured in these hartals. You are not ashamed that BNP is moving on the lines of the AL by holding these hartals? OK, so the AL is bad (in your opinion). Lets accept that for a minute. So the BNP is doing the EXACT SAME THING as AL, yet you support them?

You are just clinging on to straws because this is irrelevant if someone comment on injuries or not it is part of protest and one has to suffer for gaining their rights.

Egyptians did suffer far more injuries and same is the situation in India. In last few months we have seen bandhs again and again sometimes over quota of certain community of Hindus and some times renaming and so on. SO your argument is just a LAME excuse.


Your newspaper has crosses its limits and as always like Bharatis it considered it its right to dictate Bangladeshis.

@ towplustowisfour :NOTE: Plz dont talk about hartals we have seen BJP and groupies doing so often so should we ask you are not ashamed of it?

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

Pioneer in my view is considered a better newspaper than Times of India groups of media So it was the cheapest thing coming from Pioneers to say that Bangladeshi political parties should not hold protest against ruling party over some ill-planned projects that have less public support.

Editorial in a news paper is never a personal opinion. According to international standard of journalism an editorial always represents the official policy of a media outlet. as according to same rules you can have an opinion over issues of other countries that have SOME relevance with your country BUT An Indian saying that Republicans should not criticise conservatives over internal issues of US is like tress passing . a crime than even poking your nose in your neighbour's house.

An opinion or critical piece from Bharati media throwing light on this/these project/s of BD pointing out merits and demerits would have been better than getting angry at BD political parties and ORDERING them not to holding protest over their internal issues which has NO relevance with India is indeed in a bad taste. rather it shows YOU ARE BULLYING BANGLADESHIS.

OK, first of all I agree that the Pioneer has a much better reputation than ToI. And the fact that the piece was cleared by the editors for publishing means that it has their tacit approval.

However, does that mean that writing a critical piece on the internal matters of another country is 'trespassing'? If so, what about the multiple editorials written in newspapers nowadays about Egyptian crisis. Are they 'trespassing'? What about Pakistani newspapers commenting on 'Babri Masjid' case, are they trespassing as well? How can you, as an international journalist call an editorial piece trespassing?

And how can an Editorial piece in a newspaper in India be an ORDER to Bangladeshis? Did you even read the article?

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

do you even understand the concept behind hartal? the recent price hikes and the many more govt failures are the reason behind this hartals, and although I don't support any sort of hartal, I think this hartals are pretty justifiable. During the BNP regime, Awami league called hartals to put Khaleda out of power, but this hartals are not for Sheikh Hasina to step down but more like a wake up call.

Fine, I respect your opinion. But the newspaper is also entitled to it's opinion. I hope you realize that.

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

You are just clinging on to straws because this is irrelevant if someone comment on injuries or not it is part of protest and one has to suffer for gaining their rights.

Egyptians did suffer far more injuries and same is the situation in India. In last few months we have seen bandhs again and again sometimes over quota of certain community of Hindus and some times renaming and so on. SO your argument is just a LAME excuse.


Your newspaper has crosses its limits and as always like Bharatis it considered it its right to dictate Bangladeshis.

@ towplustowisfour :NOTE: Plz dont talk about hartals we have seen BJP and groupies doing so often so should we ask you are not ashamed of it?

I'm sorry I don't understand what you're trying to say. In my post quoted by you I was just pointing out the hypocrisy of the poster saying that their Hartals were justified because AL also held hartals, and Indian media has no right to comment on these. I was defending the right of the Indian media to write whatever they want. I personally don't give a damn if Bangladeshi decide to burn their country down. It doesn't concern me at all.

 

[Spring Onion]

OK, first of all I agree that the Pioneer has a much better reputation than ToI. And the fact that the piece was cleared by the editors for publishing means that it has their tacit approval.

However, does that mean that writing a critical piece on the internal matters of another country is 'trespassing'? If so, what about the multiple editorials written in newspapers nowadays about Egyptian crisis. Are they 'trespassing'? What about Pakistani newspapers commenting on 'Babri Masjid' case, are they trespassing as well? How can you, as an international journalist call an editorial piece trespassing?

And how can an Editorial piece in a newspaper in India be an ORDER to Bangladeshis? Did you even read the article?

Egypt crisis is completely different thing. the entire world wrote about French, Russian, Iranian revolution.

Comparing a mass change with a small internal issue of BD is silly.

And FYI passing of bad editorial by the paper high ups shows that Indian paper has this policy of meddling in national affairs of Bangladesh.

one wonders when Indian media should have been more concerned with own national issues it has opted for defending BD political party against another political party of that country

seems Indian paper is a personal secretary of AL

 

[Spring Onion]

I'm sorry I don't understand what you're trying to say. In my post quoted by you I was just pointing out the hypocrisy of the poster saying that their Hartals were justified because AL also held hartals, and Indian media has no right to comment on these. I was defending the right of the Indian media to write whatever they want. I personally don't give a damn if Bangladeshi decide to burn their country down. It doesn't concern me at all.

defending right of Indian media to dictate which political party of the neighbour should protest and which should not??

lolzz if your bharati media comes up such dictation regrading Pakistan we will simply show it our finger and shut it up.

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

Egypt crisis is completely different thing. the entire world wrote about French, Russian, Iranian revolution.

Comparing a mass change with a small internal issue of BD is silly.

OK, next time Indian papers will take advice from you for what is a mass change and what is a small internal matter.

And FYI passing of bad editorial by the paper high ups shows that Indian paper has this policy of meddling in national affairs of Bangladesh.

Again, I fail to understand how publishing an article is 'meddling in internal matters' of Bangladesh. If so, you Pakistani Journalists are guilty of interfering in Indian internal matters every day

 

[twoplustwoisfour]

defending right of Indian media to dictate which political party of the neighbour should protest and which should not??

Of course, an article published by an India paper, is a DICTATION to it's neighbour.

You don't know how silly you are sounding in this conversation.

 

[Spring Onion]

OK, next time Indian papers will take advice from you for what is a mass change and what is a small internal matter.

It needs some brain to understand what is mass change what is small protest against an ill-planned infrastructure project. So never mind your media wont be helped by merely advice unless it develops a brain

Again, I fail to understand how publishing an article is 'meddling in internal matters' of Bangladesh. If so, you Pakistani Journalists are guilty of interfering in Indian internal matters every day

read it again and try to understand it is not an opinion article but rather Indian frustration and poking nose in BD internal matters.

 

[Skies]

Who will make Indians understand that India denies its illegal-n-inhuman border killing, inference in our politics and greedy interests in supporting AL only-n-blindly? Who will?! Or Indians are not wise enough to understand why they are repulsive to us?

 

[Spring Onion]

Who will make Indians understand that India denies its illegal-n-inhuman border killing, inference in our politics and interests in supporting AL only-n-blindly? Who will?! Or Indians are not wise enough to understand why they are repulsive to us?

They can support AL but their dictating that BD people should not hold protest over purely national projects is the dumbest thing coming from Indian paper

 

[Md Akmal]

do you even understand the concept behind hartal? the recent price hikes and the many more govt failures are the reason behind this hartals, and although I don't support any sort of hartal, I think this hartals are pretty justifiable. During the BNP regime, Awami league called hartals to put Khaleda out of power, but this hartals are not for Sheikh Hasina to step down but more like a wake up call.

@ Donnot bother saleen_s7, Hasina is awaiting like the consequence of Hosne Mubarrak of Egypt. She does not have any shame. Talking all rot everyday and blaming oppossion parties. Her deputy Depu Moni yesterday said in press that present govt is losing Middle East labour market due to the wrong policy of BNP govt. BNP is out of power the last 4 years and still they are blaming. Day before yesterday, PM said in parliament that for the share market and price hike BNP and Jammats are responsible. And their best friend from Delhi and Calcutta are praising SK Hasina. What a hipocracy ? Our present Bengali "Jano Kontho" daily newspaper is being owned by the Indian businessman. After the killing of Fallani by BSF, some political leaders want to visit her home town at Kurigram but not allowed even section 144 was imposed in that locality. In which country we are living ?

 

[kobiraaz]

Sleeping. Sue them if you want to.

But I'm more concerned about the fact that you don't care whether people are injured in these hartals. You are not ashamed that BNP is moving on the lines of the AL by holding these hartals? OK, so the AL is bad (in your opinion). Lets accept that for a minute. So the BNP is doing the EXACT SAME THING as AL, yet you support them?

can anyone tell me who is injured??? common people by bnp activists?? or bnp activists by police ??

 

[fallstuff]

@ Donnot bother saleen_s7, Hasina is awaiting like the consequence of Hosne Mubarrak of Egypt. She does not have any shame. Talking all rot everyday and blaming oppossion parties. Her deputy Depu Moni yesterday said in press that present govt is losing Middle East labour market due to the wrong policy of BNP govt. BNP is out of power the last 4 years and still they are blaming. Day before yesterday, PM said in parliament that for the share market and price hike BNP and Jammats are responsible. And their best friend from Delhi and Calcutta are praising SK Hasina. What a hipocracy ? Our present Bengali "Jano Kontho" daily newspaper is being owned by the Indian businessman. After the killing of Fallani by BSF, some political leaders want to visit her home town at Kurigram but not allowed even section 144 was imposed in that locality. In which country we are living ?

Interesting news. Even the land of free doesn't allow media ownership by foreign individuals. NBC sued FOX because Rupert Murdoch was not a U.S citizen.