What's new

Bangladesh to implement Indian correctional system in prisons

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes you speak Bengali right? Okay be proud of it, no one's stopping you. But Bengali language isn't Islamic by any measure, neither by script nor lexicon. I don't know what your primary identity is- Muslim or Bangladeshi. I'll leave it there for you to ponder over

There is a such thing called Bengali Muslim ethnic group. If you look in historical text book we were referred to as Bengali Muslims or the Mohammedans of Bengal. Indians suffer from inferiority complex, it's evident in their film industry, media outlets, in every aspect of your bollywood life somewhere there is an obsessed maniac who is trying to find the "fair & lovely" in life.
 
Have posted about it a lot. Bengali language is a muslim language. You want to debate?
Okay then write some Bengali for me will you (in Roman script of course 8-)). Its an Islamic language you claim, then it must have a high percentage of Arabic and Persian loanwords. I have learnt Urdu, so hopefully would be able to catch the Farsi and Arabic words lol, other than the expected Sanskrit elements

There is a such thing called Bengali Muslim ethnic group. If you look in historical text book we were referred to as Bengali Muslims or the Mohammedans of Bengal. Indians suffer from inferiority complex, it's evident in their film industry, media outlets, in every aspect of your bollywood life somewhere there is an obsessed maniac who is trying to find the "fair & lovely" in life.
I am asking you what's your primary identity- Muslim or Bangladeshi? Not that hard to answer is it. You guys protested against Urdu, an Islamic language, in favour of Bengali, so I am guessing your ethnic identity comes first. Not trolling, a sincere question.
 
Lo dono hi chaley gaye :lol:

A script doesn't have any religion. Arabic Script was Arabic Script Before Muhammad was born. Arabic Language was Arabic language before Muhammad was born.


Now, Hindu Sena Dynasty that ruled Bengal from 1100 to 1200 after 400 years of Buddhist rule banned Bengali. They used Sanskrit. However Bengali didn't have any permanent established script right then.

Anyone who have read a single page on the formation of Bengali language would know that


1. Muslim Sultans brought Bangla back to court after defeating Sena Dynasty

2. The Bangla Script of today take its present form permanently during Pathan Muslim age of Bengal.

So Bengali langue is more Muslim Then Hindus.
 
A script doesn't have any religion. Arabic Script was Arabic Script Before Muhammad was born. Arabic Language was Arabic language before Muhammad was born.
Sanksrit language is considered a Vedic language for a reason. Its the carrier of Vedic culture. Similarly Arabic language is the carrier of Islamic culture...... I think you know what I mean. Bengali language isn't exactly representative of Muslim culture. Heck even the script is Vedic-based lol. Even you know the enormous influence Sanskrit has on Bengali, even more than Hindi. So its a bit puzzling why Bengali Muslims would prefer Bengali over Urdu which has thousands of Arabic and Persian loanwords, which can rightly be called a carrier of Islamic culture. Sanksrit was developed in NW India but Muslims there don't use Hindi lol. That's why I was asking what is the primary identity of you guys- Muslim or Bengali?
 
Sanksrit language is considered a Vedic language for a reason. Its the carrier of Vedic culture. Similarly Arabic language is the carrier of Islamic culture...... I think you know what I mean. Bengali language isn't exactly representative of Muslim culture. Heck even the script is Vedic-based lol. Even you know the enormous influence Sanskrit has on Bengali, even more than Hindi. So its a bit puzzling why Bengali Muslims would prefer Bengali over Urdu which has thousands of Arabic and Persian loanwords, which can rightly be called a carrier of Islamic culture. Sanksrit was developed in NW India but Muslims there don't use Hindi lol. That's why I was asking what is the primary identity of you guys- Muslim or Bengali?

I am busy. Talk to you l8r.
 
Sanksrit language is considered a Vedic language for a reason. Its the carrier of Vedic culture. Similarly Arabic language is the carrier of Islamic culture...... I think you know what I mean. Bengali language isn't exactly representative of Muslim culture. Heck even the script is Vedic-based lol. Even you know the enormous influence Sanskrit has on Bengali, even more than Hindi. So its a bit puzzling why Bengali Muslims would prefer Bengali over Urdu which has thousands of Arabic and Persian loanwords, which can rightly be called a carrier of Islamic culture. Sanksrit was developed in NW India but Muslims there don't use Hindi lol. That's why I was asking what is the primary identity of you guys- Muslim or Bengali?

Arabic Was a pagan language. Islam claimed it. Urdu is an Indian language. Islam claimed it. Farsi was a pagan language. Islam claimed it. Why can't be Bengali claimed? Use your common sense and imagine You are in 2116. Bengali will be a muslim language because of Bangladesh. I am sure.


Why do Ashraf and Ajlaf Muslims exists? You guys where the inferior Ajlaf Muslims. That's why all Bangladeshis claim to be of foreign descent but look nothing like a Pathan.

Where did you get that Ashrafs were Pathan?

Plus there is no Ashraf Atraf BS in Bangladesh
 
You're living in a delusional make believe world if you believe that Pathan rulers considered you as equals. Remember that 99% of Bangladeshis are low caste converts.

You need to show links or source of your claim.. You just cant claim. Especially We are talking about an era when slaves were rulers like Mamlukes.
 
MOf1XP8.jpg

Your ancestors worked for the Hindu Brahmin zamindars. You know this as well as I do. Only Hindu Brahmins where given respect by the Pathan rulers.

There were no Jamindari system before Muslims came. Most of the Jamindaris were Muslim settlers known as Bhuiyan. I am guessing You have very little knowledge about Bengal History..
 
You're living in a delusional make believe world if you believe that Pathan rulers considered you as equals. Remember that 99% of Bangladeshis are low caste converts.
In bengal you hardly find any Khatrio caste because they allconverted to buddhism to become the ruling class. Only the bhramin and chmar like you left to behold the Hindu religion. Buddhist later converted to Islam to remain as ruling class along with central asian sher.
Now go back and ponder why you still remain as chamar class despite having the opportunity to embrace islam and emacipate yourself and your next generation.
 
Arabic Was a pagan language. Islam claimed it. Urdu is an Indian language. Islam claimed it. Farsi was a pagan language. Islam claimed it. Why can't be Bengali claimed? Use your common sense and imagine You are in 2116. Bengali will be a muslim language because of Bangladesh. I am sure.
Arabic is no more a pagan language. It became the language of Islam when the Prophet of Islam received the first revelation. The Holy Quran is written in Arabic language. Isn't it then obvious that languages which contain more Arabic loanwords are inherenty more Islamic in nature? Like Farsi which is also considered an Islamic language. Farsi has the highest number of Arabic loanwords. Urdu has so much Arabic and Farsi loanwords to which Bengali can't even compare.

Its completely opposite for Bengali. With the 90% Sanskrit lexicon of Bengali, you can't claim Bengali to be an Islamic language in any way. The Vedas, Upanishads, Puranas are all written in Sanskrit. If anything Bengali is more representative of Vedic culture than anything remotely Islamic. And its all well-known that you guys favoured Bengali over Urdu, an Islamic language. So naturally, aspersions would be cast on your primary identity- are you Muslim or Bengali first?
 
Arabic is no more a pagan language. It became the language of Islam when the Prophet of Islam received the first revelation. The Holy Quran is written in Arabic language. Isn't it then obvious that languages which contain more Arabic loanwords are inherenty more Islamic in nature? Like Farsi which is also considered an Islamic language. Farsi has the highest number of Arabic loanwords. Urdu has so much Arabic and Farsi loanwords to which Bengali can't even compare.

Its completely opposite for Bengali. With the 90% Sanskrit lexicon of Bengali, you can't claim Bengali to be an Islamic language in any way. The Vedas, Upanishads, Puranas are all written in Sanskrit. If anything Bengali is more representative of Vedic culture than anything remotely Islamic. And its all well-known that you guys favoured Bengali over Urdu, an Islamic language. So naturally, aspersions would be cast on your primary identity- are you Muslim or Bengali first?

Wait My dear Where did you get that 90% Bengali words are Sanskrit?

Anyway Arabic words are this important then No other Language should be chosen instead of Arabic..Urdu Farsi everything should be discarded because the language of Quran already exists.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Back
Top Bottom