What's new

Bangladesh liberation film opens old wounds

HAIDER

ELITE MEMBER
May 21, 2006
33,850
14
33,606
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
DHAKA: A Bangladeshi film about a love affair set in the country’s bloody 1971 liberation struggle against Pakistan has stirred up heated debate, prompting the distributor to pull it from cinemas.

Meherjaan: A Story of War and Love, which features some of south Asia’s biggest stars including Victor Banerjee and Jaya Bachchan, wife of Indian movie legend Amitabh Bachchan, was released last month to critical acclaim.

But the plot, charting a romance between a local girl and a Pakistani soldier, has hit a raw nerve in Bangladesh, where a new war crimes tribunal has just begun prosecuting suspected collaborators.

“I fought in the liberation war but after we released this film, my fellow freedom fighters called me a collaborator and traitor,” the owner of the film’s distribution company, Habibur Rahman Khan, told AFP.

“We’ve stopped distributing the film because critics said it degraded the sufferings of the Bangladeshi women raped in the war,” he said.

In the film, Meherjaan, a Bangladeshi girl, falls in love with a Pakistani soldier who gets court-martialed for refusing to participate in war crimes and atrocities.

A barrage of criticism in the Bangladeshi press and on the Internet said the film’s romantic storyline undermined the suffering of the estimated 200,000 Bangladeshi women raped by Pakistani forces during the war.

Bangladesh’s government says three million people were killed by the occupying forces and local collaborators in the nine-month struggle that saw then-East Pakistan emerge as an independent Bangladesh on December 6, 1971.

“Meherjaan has insulted the spirit of the country’s liberation war and our history,” said four writers, including a woman who was raped by Pakistani troops, in a joint article in the Prothom Alo newspaper.

“Under the guise of a story about love and war, it’s a film about insult and deception,” they wrote.

Pakistani war crimes are a sensitive issue in Bangladesh, but public feeling has intensified since the government set up the International War Crimes Tribunal in March last year.

The tribunal aims to try the local collaborators for crimes including genocide, arson, rape and looting. It has arrested five people, all of whom are also leading opposition figures, in the last six months.

The main opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) has dismissed the trial as politically motivated.

The government has not yet said whether the court will pursue cases against individual Pakistani soldiers, but private campaigners have provided the court with a list of 195 army officers accused of atrocities.

The film, because of its positive depiction of a Pakistani soldier, has been “unofficially banned”, Farzana Boby, an assistant director on the film, told AFP.

“It is unfortunate. All we have tried to do is to make a good film. It has been pulled even though it was drawing bigger crowds than any other major hit film in Bangladesh,” she said.

The crew and directors have also become targets of hate-campaigns by people who cannot tolerate a “different narrative of our liberation war,” she said.

“They are angry because our story does not follow the dominant theme of the struggle. To them, all Pakistanis were butchers during the war. There cannot be a good-natured Pakistani soldier who rebels against the army,” she said.

Some industry professionals have lamented the angry reception the film has been given.

“It’s unfortunate there is such a huge controversy over such a good film. We live in a democratic country and everyone has the right to tell their own story,” film director Chasi Nazrul Islam told AFP. “We get stronger if we listen to all voices.”
Bangladesh liberation film opens old wounds | Entertainment | DAWN.COM
 
The news was in Telegraph some weeks ago, I didn't post it because of sensitivity of the news.
 
Well, truth and ground reality never change. If " we" the Pakistani guilty of such bad acts then WE should face the reality . Not to runway, this letter is published in most respectable media outlet of Pakistan.
The fact is, if an Indian post it then people might take it as troll , that's why i posted.


But troll is never welcomed in this forum.
 
Anyway personally I don't think there is anything wrong to depict a soldier in positive hue as there must have been good, bad and ugly in PA, granted the ugliest(s) made it to media. History should be viewed as it happened, not as a religious text which can't be questioned.
 
Since i know nothing about the film or its story-line, i can't comment on the film itself.
But the episodes of exploitation of women during the occupation was indeed a horrendous experience to the people it happened to, as well as the people who witnessed or knew about the occurrences. And that was just part of it. There was another issue- that of the pregnancies that resulted. Not all of the victims could or did abort the foetuses. So for them, it was a hell that they did not just remember but had become a part of their body. Later was another extremely humanitarian problem, the children born of these atrocities. Whose children were they? Nobodys, yet they were there in flesh and blood.

Some effort was made to find adoptive parents/foster homes for these "nobody's children". But there were hardly any homes for these children forthcoming in the newly born country or in the neighborhood. So most of them went overseas and a large number of them reached Canada among other countries. i know of all this because i know somebody who worked very actively in this campaign. Those children have grown up and a substantial amount of time has passed.

But for the victims of this huge tragedy or anybody even remotely connected to it, there must be so many aspects remaining. We can only try to imagine it but we will never be able to understand it.
 
Well, truth and ground reality never change. If " we" the Pakistani guilty of such bad acts then WE should face the reality . Not to runway, this letter is published in most respectable media outlet of Pakistan.
The fact is, if an Indian post it then people might take it as troll , that's why i posted.


But troll is never welcomed in this forum.

@ Haider,
i understand and appreciate your sentiments in posting this piece. There cannot be any justification to use this as a pretext to troll or post any stupid or insensitive comments. That will (IMO) be as cruel as that episode of human history.
 
I like Japanese a lot for moving on and by making US their biggest trade partner after WW II (every one know what US did to them in WWII) . Well if Bangladesh want to keep their hate alive to support their masters in Propaganda of hate against Pakistan its up to them.
 
I like Japanese a lot for moving on and by making US their biggest trade partner after WW II (every one know what US did to them in WWII) . Well if Bangladesh want to keep their hate alive to support their masters in Propaganda of hate against Pakistan its up to them.

For God sake, Pakistan did nothing to them, Pakistan was fighting the war with terrorists, like we are fighting today. The Muktis were trained & funded by our enemy for terrorism in that part & they raped & killed non-Bengali peoples too.

Pakistanis are so stupid or innocent that they beleive what lie the media tells them. 2 lakh rapes, my foot.:hitwall: 3 million killed:argh::argh::blah:
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom