Baloch Separatists Should Give Up on False Hope of American or Indian Help : Malik Siraj Akbar

[Areesh]

Despite that drama Modi did at Red fort last year no actual help is coming b!tches. Not anytime soon.

Deep resentment and genuine grievances aside, the Baloch nationalists do not have a solid game plan to win their battle against Beijing and Islamabad. For years, their under-resourced movement has been based on the false hope that someday the world order will change and global powers such as the United States or India will come to help them win their freedom.

As things stand today, no country in the world, including the US and India, seems to favor destabilizing or disintegrating Pakistan. I talk to a lot of Baloch leaders and activists. They don’t seem to get this reality or at least acknowledge it.

It is indeed unwise to base an entire movement merely on a policy of hope. The miracle of foreign assistance for the Baloch did not happen in the past decade; it will probably not occur any time soon.

http://www.atimes.com/chinas-balochistan-problem/

 

[Quibbler]

I wondered if they said the same thing to Bangladesh.

 

[graphican]

No no, wait. Both USA and India did wanted to destabilise Pakistan - and they tried their best to create insurgency in Baluchistan - but its a second story that how badly they failed. Guess who opened BLA's office in Israel (ehm USA) and who's monkey is Kulbhusan Yadev (ehm ehm India).

 

[Areesh]

I wondered if they said the same thing to Bangladesh.

Guess you didn't change your calender since 1971

 

[manga]

Despite that drama Modi did at Red fort last year no actual help is coming b!tches. Not anytime soon.
/

You are right about it though, there is nothing from india to help balochistan struggle.
Whatever there is of there own natural struggle.

 

[Areesh]

You are right about it though, there is nothing from india to help balochistan struggle.
Whatever there is of there own natural struggle.

Just like Kashmir??? Natural struggle

But Aslam Achu was killed in Afghanistan. So it isn't that natural either.

The thing is India's supported is limited to giving money and weapons. And nothing more than that. And the way things are going nothing more isn't coming either.

 

[Arsalan]

Just like Kashmir??? Natural struggle

But Aslam Achu was killed in Afghanistan. So it isn't that natural either.

The thing is India's supported is limited to giving money and weapons. And nothing more than that. And the way things are going nothing more isn't coming either.

India have been caught with its pants down in Baluchistan. There are caught spies, admission of Baloch separatists about finance and training coming from India, links to Afghanistan and India's presence in Afghanistan. It is so obvious that no one is listening to that propaganda anymore. They planned a dangerous game for us over there but the execution was poor and its almost over already.

 

[Rajesh Kumar]

Despite that drama Modi did at Red fort last year no actual help is coming b!tches. Not anytime soon.



http://www.atimes.com/chinas-balochistan-problem/

IS changing the title make feel you Happy?? Now Almost maximum Pakistan friends are following same story and changing the title and start trolling....

Let me Post proper details..

Titile
China’s Balochistan problem

On Tuesday, news broke that Aslam Baloch, the mastermind of the recent attack on the Chinese Consulate in Karachi, Pakistan, had been killed in a suicide attack in Afghanistan. While no group has accepted responsibility for the attack, the greatest celebrations were seen among Pakistani military officials, the country’s right-wing media, and centrist politicians.

One senator who formerly served as the interior minister in the country’s largest province, Balochistan, which borders Afghanistan, stunned many by calling the suicide attack in the neighboring country and the loss of human lives “great news.” This provided analysts with ample reason to suspect Pakistan or its Taliban proxies in Afghanistan of plotting the terrorist attack.

The dailyReport

Must-reads from across Asia - directly to your inbox
There is a broader context and background to why a Pakistani politician would rejoice in a suicide attack in neighboring Afghanistan, a country that, ironically, desperately needs Pakistan’s support to achieve peace and stability.

The attack eliminated one of the top leaders of the Baloch Liberation Army, an underground armed group that has been waging an insurgency in Pakistan for an independent Baloch homeland for more than a decade. Although Pakistan has insisted for several years that India was supporting groups like the BLA via Afghanistan, Islamabad has produced hardly any evidence to substantiate the claims of Indian assistance for the Baloch movement, nor could it accurately pinpoint where the Baloch fighters were hiding in Afghanistan.

The only evidence that the Pakistanis keep referring to is the arrest of an alleged Indian spy from Balochistan in March 2016 whom they describe as the architect, master trainer, and financier of the Baloch rebellion. That does not satisfactorily address the remaining question as to why Balochistan had been the epicenter of resistance, unrest and resentment toward the central government for six decades before this Indian spy was arrested.

The killing of the BLA leader and his colleagues is a big deal for Pakistan because the attack, for the first time, provides evidence that Baloch leaders and activists were actually living in Afghanistan.

In recent years, the Baloch sense of insecurity has dramatically increased because of China’s growing presence in Balochistan under the umbrella of CPEC

In recent years, the Baloch sense of insecurity has dramatically increased because of China’s growing presence in Balochistan under the umbrella of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). While the majority of Pakistanis are excited about the Chinese investment, the Balochs, who have had a horrific history of being exploited and militarily knocked down by the Pakistanis, fear the arrival of the Chinese because they suspect China and Pakistan of collaborating to marginalize them further in the name of “development.”

In a desperate attempt to scare the Chinese or at least convey a warning, three activists from the BLA carried out a failed attack on the Chinese Consulate in Karachi on November 23. Security officials responded swiftly and killed all three attackers. However, the BLA and its supporters did not necessarily view the outcome as a failure. Since the attack targeted the Chinese diplomatic mission, it drew more media attention than a normal attack by insurgents inside Pakistan; the Baloch guerrillas believed that at least it helped them convey a message to the world that they oppose the Chinese presence in Balochistan.

However, the attack put the Pakistani authorities under pressure not only to make sure that they went after groups that threaten Chinese personnel, projects and interests inside the country but also to take measures to guard China’s multibillion-dollar investment in CPEC.

Apparently, Islamabad isn’t going so far as to take credit for the attack that killed the senior BLA leader, but it will still happily walk up to the Chinese with some “great news,” as the senator from Balochistan put it, that the enemy has been weakened and the mastermind of the consulate attack has been brought to justice.

Coincidently, I had interviewed Aslam Baloch four days before his assassination. He sounded obsessed with and incensed by China and its growing activities in Balochistan. I asked why his organization had executed the Karachi strike; he said, “The objectives were obvious. China and Pakistan are partnering to challenge the future of the Baloch people under the disguise of development. They want to outnumber us in Balochistan.”

Unrepentant of the consulate attack and unafraid to continue the resistance, Baloch, 43, ruled out the prospects of any compromise with the Chinese. All he wanted was for Beijing to “give up all your exploitative developmental projects and get out of Balochistan.” I asked if any terms and conditions could bring all sides to the negotiation table; there was no such hint.

“We are fighting a war for our survival,” he said. “We can’t afford to compromise on the collective future of the Baloch people.”

Deep resentment and genuine grievances aside, the Baloch nationalists do not have a solid game plan to win their battle against Beijing and Islamabad. For years, their under-resourced movement has been based on the false hope that someday the world order will change and global powers such as the United States or India will come to help them win their freedom.

As things stand today, no country in the world, including the US and India, seems to favor destabilizing or disintegrating Pakistan. I talk to a lot of Baloch leaders and activists. They don’t seem to get this reality or at least acknowledge it.

It is indeed unwise to base an entire movement merely on a policy of hope. The miracle of foreign assistance for the Baloch did not happen in the past decade; it will probably not occur any time soon.

With US President Donald Trump’s recent announcement to the withdrawal of 7,000 of American troops from Afghanistan, the Baloch nationalists will have to prepare for harsh days ahead, as Afghanistan under the influence of the Taliban will no longer be a safe sanctuary.

With China, Pakistan, Iran and a Taliban-led Afghanistan, the Balochs will be surrounded by hostile forces on all sides. But while it might seem tempting and comfortable for the big powers to eliminate the Baloch nationalists militarily using proxies such as the Taliban, they must exercise restraint and find a way for a political settlement. There is no shortcut to peace. All stakeholders must commit to undergoing the ordeal of tough negotiations and agree to give up their stated positions on various policy issues.

If proxy groups or local death squads are used to find a prompt resolution in Balochistan, it might lead to a new humanitarian crisis and bloodbath. The Chinese deputy chief of mission in Islamabad has been belligerent, condescending and disrespectful in his public diplomacy and outreach to the Pakistani public in general and the Balochs in particular. This is deeply disconcerting and such behavior needs a quick correction.

The thousands of Balochs who have migrated to Iran or Afghanistan because of the ongoing conflict should be assured that their home is safe and they will not be attacked or harassed if they return. They should be resettled and rehabilitated honorably instead of left at the mercy of the groups that are imbued with a spirit of revenge and punishment toward their enemies.

All parties must listen to one another’s perspectives and find a peaceful solution to the prolonged insurgency in Balochistan, which has claimed thousands of lives. China must do its share to address the Baloch reservations to ensure the success of its engagement in Balochistan. If Pakistan can support talks with the Taliban, why can’t it do the same in Balochistan?

http://www.atimes.com/chinas-balochistan-problem/

 

[Areesh]

IS changing the title make feel you Happy?? Now Almost maximum Pakistan friends are following same story and changing the title and start trolling....

Awesome work genius. I myself share the link to original article for anyone's reading

Why you bharatis are so low IQ morons???

The thing is article basically says that Baloch separatists should simply living on false hope of Indian help and have dialogue with Pakistani government.

Even then the whole article supports Pakistan and destroys all bharati delusions about Balochistan.

 

[Tokhme khar]

Pakistan needs to get its house in order. Just kill these mofo's!........This same shit was going on in our sistan va balochistan in the 70's and 80's, but we fukking genocided these cunts!

Now our problem is that these cunts want to push drugs, people and arms into our side from Pak side.

Just kill them all. Show no mercy. Otherwise it won't end.

P.S. we had to do the same in Iranian kordistan. Just kill them if they fight the government.

 

[Trango Towers]

I wondered if they said the same thing to Bangladesh.

But this is pakistan

 

[Rajesh Kumar]

Awesome work genius. I myself share the link to original article for anyone's reading

Why you bharatis are so low IQ morons???

The thing is article basically says that Baloch separatists should simply living on false hope of Indian help and have dialogue with Pakistani government.

Even then the whole article supports Pakistan and destroys all bharati delusions about Balochistan.

Nope..... Can you please point out?
Changing the subject line is your theory, Sir.....Author Didn't say anything About India and US in whole Article.

This is here now common behavior to change the Title and start trolling.....

 

[Areesh]

Nope..... Can you please point out?
Changing the subject line is your theory, Sir.....Author Didn't say anything About India and US in whole Article.

This is here now common behavior to change the Title and start trolling.....

Didn't say about America or India

Did you even bother to read the OP or jumped to hit the reply button without thinking like other brainless bharatis?

 

[Crystal-Clear]

baloch separatists were defeted the time akber bhugti died . they cant do anything big now .

 

[Rajesh Kumar]

Didn't say about America or India

Did you even bother to read the OP or jumped to hit the reply button without thinking like other brainless bharatis?

Yes ...Sir I read it properly... you have to read it.. Let me highlights some basics points


As things stand today, no country in the world, including the US and India, seems to favor destabilizing or disintegrating Pakistan. I talk to a lot of Baloch leaders and activists. They don’t seem to get this reality or at least acknowledge it.

In recent years, the Baloch sense of insecurity has dramatically increased because of China’s growing presence in Balochistan under the umbrella of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). While the majority of Pakistanis are excited about the Chinese investment, the Balochs, who have had a horrific history of being exploited and militarily knocked down by the Pakistanis, fear the arrival of the Chinese because they suspect China and Pakistan of collaborating to marginalize them further in the name of “development.”

With China, Pakistan, Iran and a Taliban-led Afghanistan, the Balochs will be surrounded by hostile forces on all sides. But while it might seem tempting and comfortable for the big powers to eliminate the Baloch nationalists militarily using proxies such as the Taliban, they must exercise restraint and find a way for a political settlement. There is no shortcut to peace. All stakeholders must commit to undergoing the ordeal of tough negotiations and agree to give up their stated positions on various policy issues.

Brainless .....anyone can see that who is brainless.