What's new

ARE YOU ASHAMED OF BEING INDIAN?

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Sep 20, 2014
9,318
-28
11,634
Country
India
Location
India
Are you ashamed of being Indian?
May 27, 2015,12:04 AMISTSagarika GhoseinBloody Mary|Edit Page,India|TOI

Modi is Hero No. 1 for NRIs, but their ‘long distance nationalism’ is dangerous for India

Prime Minister Modi recently told an audience of mostly expat Indians in Seoul: “Earlier, you felt ashamed of being born Indian. Now you feel proud to represent the country.” NRI crowds loudly cheered the first Indian leader who seemed to understand why they had left India, who even assuaged their perpetual guilt at abandoning the motherland. Once unfairly lampooned as shallow wealth seekers, the NRI feels understood by Modi.

Benedict Anderson coined the term ‘long distance nationalism’ and of the ‘imagined communities’ that migrants create. Today, the internet creates a sense of immediacy to an idealised ‘homeland’ without the benefit of real lived experience. This means that passions of expatriate communities can be easily inflamed as NRIs wrestle with their own alienation from mainstream societies in their adoptive countries. Precisely because the NRI constantly needs to define his identity in terms of religion and ethnicity, that identity politics and self-assertion on the global stage goes down so well with them.

From Shanghai to Toronto, from New York to Sydney one of the dominant images of Modi in the last year have been his ‘performances’ for NRI audiences. Modi bonds with overseas Indians like no other Indian PM. Such has been the euphoric reception that Modi gets from overseas Indians that he has himself almost created an After Modi (AM) and a Before Modi (BM) era, a rotten past of degradation and misery, all of it magically transformed on 26 May 2014 into a potential boomtown Great Nation. By doing so Modi has become the symbol of the long distance nationalism of the NRI.

Yet NRIs do not vote in India, and nor should they, because all politics is ultimately local. Democratic politics is rooted in the ground realities of municipality and town and not in imaginary ideas and hankering for an idyllic Bharat from millions of miles away. Modi’s fortunes are not going to be decided in Texas or Tampa Bay but in Barabanki and Kozhikode, and the distressed farmer in Haryana and Uttar Pradesh may be unwilling to buy into Modi’s imaginary vision of a sudden leap forward. 1,400 projects are still stalled, growth in manufacturing is still sluggish, one in two girls are still married off by the age of 18, India still ranks 186th out of 189 countries in enforcing business contracts.

Modi’s election promise of five crore jobs in five years is sounding like an election ‘jumla’ and slogans like Swachh Bharat are still not producing any visible results. Conversely, maternal and child mortality have been showing a downward slide through the last five years, literacy levels are climbing rapidly, the middle class born after Manmohanomics now numbers almost a billion adults with wealth anywhere between $10,000-$1,00,000 range. The new aspirational middle class in India is hardly ashamed to be Indian.

So why is Modi the NRI Hero No. 1? Expatriate communities often tend to be far more conservative than domestic ones, precisely because the assaults on self-esteem are so great in adoptive countries. The Zionist cause was and is championed by American Jews. The Khalistan demand was run by expatriate Sikhs in Canada. Many Irish Americans supported those in Ireland waging war for the Irish identity. LTTE received direction and leadership from Tamils in Europe. A Z Phizo led the Naga National Council from London.

In the 80s and 90s BJP reached out to NRIs by emphasising religious nationalism, projecting India as the ‘land of Ram’. VHP’s international front was used to raise money for various Ram mandir agitations. Recall Vajpayee’s famous speech in Staten Island where he spoke about his pride in being a swayamsevak. While the front row at many of Modi’s speeches have been overseas friends of BJP and VHP, the PM’s pitch has also revolved around a strong and assertive India. So Modi taps not only into the religious minded expat Hindu but also into those affluent NRIs who do not want to be reminded of India’s darker side or harsh realities. Modi has so far visited rich NRIs of the developed world, not the remittance-sending daily wagers in the Gulf.

High achieving NRIs are increasingly achieving material success. But in white-dominated Christian societies, they are the perpetual outsiders, even though the tide is turning. Recent British elections show Indian-origin Britons moving out of the ghetto, into mainstream political life. For them Modi with his unabashedly bombastic and upwardly mobile style is the natural mascot.

Yet there is a dichotomy in unleashing nationalist and jingoist messages to audiences which thrive on the open and developed environments of their host country. Forever fighting their own demons, NRIs applaud a tough leader vowing to teach Pakistan, journalists, pesky NGOs and other ‘anti-nationals’ a lesson. Tagore warned constantly of the dangers of nationalism and Gandhi made sure that his nationalism included all, even English people. Nationalism when defined as war on anyone critical of Modi government can become an exercise in polarising society rather than uniting it. In fact, NRI nationalism is dangerous for India.

As a suggestion, why don’t NRIs who’ve voted with their feet and left India contribute to the PM’s religio-cultural Save Ganga project? Or is the NRI frenzy limited to a selfie-clicking rush and forever putting an ‘I’ before India


Are you ashamed of being Indian? - TOI Blogs
 
Sagarika is still butthurt over the beating his husband received in US by NRIs .

And she and her husband LOST their jobs at CNN IBN when AMBANI took it over

Though her husband has got another job on another channel
but now he is highly subdued
That swagger has gone
 
Seems she is puking all her anger on NRIs;so difficult for her to forget what happened to her husband in US.A good journalist should be above such biases.He or she should be able to analyse a situation without taking sides.
 
Yes Most of the NRI had been regularly embarrassed by the series of corruption scandal.
Twisting those in entire way wont be that good.
Very few NRI are ashamed of corruption.. Resident Indians have different view from non resident ones. Corruption is everywhere, not unique to India.
The true shame they felt were related to CWG( it was less about corruption more about mismanagement) and then about rape cases.
 
I think Ms Ghose forgets that unlike her , most of us don't have dads that ran Doordarshan and set her up for life with a nice cushy job. Didn't her husband personally apologize, I think with some tearing that he may not have been completely honest about the altercation he had with some NRI s in NY.
 
Indians are not ashamed of being indian , they are ashamed of the contrast between the propagated image of india and the reality of india
 
Very few NRI are ashamed of corruption.. Resident Indians have different view from non resident ones. Corruption is everywhere, not unique to India.
The true shame they felt were related to CWG( it was less about corruption more about mismanagement) and then about rape cases.
Many NRIs left India because they couldn't stand the corruption. They are if anything even more bothered by it.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Back
Top Bottom