American View: An Indian Founding Father on Indian Occupied Kashmir! [VIDEO]

[Meengla]

The latest
-------------------------
On Indian Occupied Kashmir, my channel is not only getting personal hate toward me, with threats to shut me up, but also blatant lies expressed here about the demographics of Kashmir. One of the most repeated lies is that the tragic expulsion of Kashmir Pundits in 1980s/90s turned Kashmir into a Muslim majority state. So wrong. I think justice should be given to all, including to Kashmir Pundits. I am a Christian. I will not take religious sides between the people living there. And I also acknowledge that once Hindus lived there in majority. But haven't we all replaced someone before us? I am Irish-American but also have some Cherokee Native American blood in me. So I know the loss of original land. But we can't go back centuries to justify our modern genocidal tendencies!! What India and it's bloggers are doing is to reverse the injustice of the centuries past. Wrong! Indians are hiding their genocide of Kashmir by making all kinds of lies. That is wrong and dangerous! To the peace loving people of India: Oppose your Fascist Modi Govt now before it's too late!!

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Another great commentary however, it is highly debatable whether Hindus were EVER a majority in the princely state of jk. Do not ignore the holocaust of Jammu's Muslims around partition, in front of which the numbers of Hindu Pandits recently expelled is quite paltry.

 

[Meengla]

Another great commentary however, it is highly debatable whether Hindus were EVER a majority in the princely state of jk. Do not ignore the holocaust of Jammu's Muslims around partition, in front of which the numbers of Hindu Pandits recently expelled is quite paltry.

Hindus DID rule what is now most of South Asia. That may have been centuries ago. It doesn't help denying people their ancestry. But we need to move on in a compromising way. We are going to have to live together.

In my opinion, what needs to happen is to heal the wounds on all sides. And give a reality check to those who are day-dreaming of cutting off Pakistan-China link.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Hindus DID rule what is now most of South Asia. That may have been centuries ago. It doesn't help denying people their ancestry. But we need to move on in a compromising way. We are going to have to live together.

In my opinion, what needs to happen is to heal the wounds on all sides. And give a reality check to those who are day-dreaming of cutting off Pakistan-China link.

Sir your overall sentiments are correct but why not call a spade a spade? As far as I am aware, the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir has ALWAYS been Muslim majority ever since the first available census in that state.

I'm not talking about the land prior to the inauguration of the state of j and k, because then, how far back shall we go in history? Someone else was there before Hindus were there even.

No, keep it simple. No need to "acknowledge" that Hindus were a majority in j and k ...because they never actually were.

Not only are we within our rights contemporaneously in demanding a plebiscite, but also were we within our rights historically and at any single chosen point in the entire history of the state of j and k to demand that majority interests be served by way of due democratic process, rather than the interests of a minority ruling class be served at the behest of Delhi.

If word of that truth actually gets out, the Pandits will really get their lunghees in a twist.

Notwithstanding all that, the YouTube Channel you and your wife are promoting is a great venture. Do keep it up.

 

[American Pakistani]

The fkin bharti terrorists are causing her videos to be deleted reason copy right material. While the reaction channels have way more copy righted material.

 

[Imad.Khan]

Here is the link to the 1941 census of Kashmir. Select the 2nd pdf for details

https://dspace.gipe.ac.in/xmlui/handle/10973/37337

As per the census

Muslims = 77.11%
Hindus = 20.12%
Others = 2.77%

 

[Psychic]

I will not take religious sides between the people living there. And I also acknowledge that once Hindus lived there in majority.

They converted. It's not like someone drove them out to replace them. Much like the rest of Pakistan.

I think justice should be given to all, including to Kashmir Pundits.

Yes indeed.

However it was the governor Jagmohan whose fear mongering drove the Pandits out---militant threats were a secondary cause.