What's new

Allocate Karachi NA seats based on ethnic population for betterment of city

Status
Not open for further replies.
We know muhajirs were not absolute majority in 1998 census and neither they will be in 2017 results when they come out. But MQM which is racist ethnic party win 90% of seats taking advantage of parliamentarian system.

If not divide then solution is to allocate Karachi seats on basis of ethnic population. If muhajirs are 40% of population then they get 40% of seats. If pashtuns are 20% then they get 20% of seats in Karachi and so on.

They still have more seats but it will be equally divided in mini-Pakistan :-)
Bull shit ... So if you want to treat us people like you are reasons of division in Pakistan ... you should be ashamed on your bull shit suggestion ...
 
My point is simple. Ethnic party like MQM win 95% of Karachi seats when urdu speakers are not even half of population. If MQM agenda was something else then it wouldn't matter but this isn't the case. For that reason allocation of seats on basis of ethnic groups is only way to solve Karachi problem. Only fair representation can fix Karachi issues.

Its not that simple.Show me a democracy where NA seats are allocated on the basis of ethnic population.As i said know a days MQM also gives tickets to non-urdu speakers.Sometimes in politics because of divided opposition a winning party only needs to win 30+% vote to clean sweep.
 
OP have no idea about Karachi and Urdu Speakers are around 50-55% population and there are not only Urdu speakers but Punjabi and Balochi also vote them ( not all but a quiet impressive figure )
Pashtoons are living in different areas almost outskirts of Karachi even being a handsome majority their votes strength diveded and difficult to win NA seats. PA yes! One or two they always get and recently goes to PTI.
If ANP got back more than before their votes divide again.
I am seeing MQMP,PSP,MQMH joint alliance on various seats not only in urban but also in rural to chase PPP, their only competitor.
 
Not good idea to divide and distribute seats on ethnic grounds whats next sectarian lines "shia /sunni and than followed by a "WALL" like the one they have in Israel !!??

urban population has increased and is now 55% of sindhs population all parties should join hands and beat PPP wadera shahi system and appoint next CM from Sindhs urban area no matter what ethnicity
 
Bull shit ... So if you want to treat us people like you are reasons of division in Pakistan ... you should be ashamed on your bull shit suggestion ...

I’m for giving fair representation to Karachi people and here you are crying about ethnic division. You know what is ethnic BS? A racist bhatta khor ethnic based MQM win 95% of seats while being 40% of population.

Just like in rest of Pakistan, seats in Karachi too should be allocated to represent many ethnic groups of Karachi.

Not good idea to divide and distribute seats on ethnic grounds whats next sectarian lines "shia /sunni and than followed by a "WALL" like the one they have in Israel !!??

urban population has increased and is now 55% of sindhs population all parties should join hands and beat PPP wadera shahi system and appoint next CM from Sindhs urban area no matter what ethnicity

I’m sorry but do Karachi walas live on another planet and not in Karachi? MQM win 95% seats while being 40% of population. Punjabis don’t vote for MQM and neither Baloch because its ethnic party.

Now don’t give exemple of some baloch in MQM, he looked more like Bangladeshi with Baloch surname.

I guess Maulana Abul Kalam Azad was right to a certain degree in his speech after partition at jamia masjid Delhi. These paindo Punjabis like @Kabira have more hatred, envy and jealousy for the "muhajir/Urdu speakers" than the Hindus. These idiots don't know the ABC about Pakistan's history or the history of the muslim subcontinent and therefore have no sense of Pakistaniat. In their ignorant, provincial and myopic minds they only have hate for the urdu speaking citizens of Karachi and want to suppress the identity of Urdu speakers in other parts of the country. These bigots are the biggest bane of Pakistan and infest it like maggots.

Bhaiyye please don’t be haramkhor like mullah Azad, Altaf Hussain etc. This isn’t punjab issue but Sindh and Karachi. Go put your muslim history in rear end. We are talking about Karachi here and how to fix its problems by dividing it along ethnic lines.

If bhattha khori is Pakistaniat then Altaf Hussain is one and true Pakistani.

Why re-ignite divisions in Karachi?Seats should be distributed on base of population and for administrative purposes

This administrative BS will not fly anywhere. See how these stupid people are bringing punjab when it has nothing to do with it, clearly shows their hatered over no reason. To fix this Karachi should have representation from all quartes even if muhajirs still have more seats any other.

This will encourage more Sindhi to migrate to Karachi. Time to give Karachi back to Sindhis and aplogise for 1947 mistakes.
 
I’m for giving fair representation to Karachi people and here you are crying about ethnic division. You know what is ethnic BS? A racist bhatta khor ethnic based MQM win 95% of seats while being 40% of population.

Just like in rest of Pakistan, seats in Karachi too should be allocated to represent many ethnic groups of Karachi.



I’m sorry but do Karachi walas live on another planet and not in Karachi? MQM win 95% seats while being 40% of population. Punjabis don’t vote for MQM and neither Baloch because its ethnic party.

Now don’t give exemple of some baloch in MQM, he looked more like Bangladeshi with Baloch surname.



Bhaiyye please don’t be haramkhor like mullah Azad, Altaf Hussain etc. This isn’t punjab issue but Sindh and Karachi. Go put your muslim history in rear end. We are talking about Karachi here and how to fix its problems by dividing it along ethnic lines.

If bhattha khori is Pakistaniat then Altaf Hussain is one and true Pakistani.



This administrative BS will not fly anywhere. See how these stupid people are bringing punjab when it has nothing to do with it, clearly shows their hatered over no reason. To fix this Karachi should have representation from all quartes even if muhajirs still have more seats any other.

This will encourage more Sindhi to migrate to Karachi. Time to give Karachi back to Sindhis and aplogise for 1947 mistakes.

MQM and mohajirs are two different things.Not all urdu-speakers support MQM,in the last election PTI got about 6-8 lakh votes from karachi.In sindh there are only 2 choices for voters PPP and MQM and urdu speakers are not going to vote for bhuttoism since they imposed quota system on urban sindh.
 
When will we finally move past ethnicity and become Pakistanis :( I'm from Karachi, but do not and cannot consider myself to be Mahajir. It was my grandparents who migrated from India not me or my parents. I'm Pakistani, why can't the rest of Pakistan be too!?
 
MQM and mohajirs are two different things.Not all urdu-speakers support MQM,in the last election PTI got about 6-8 lakh votes from karachi.In sindh there are only 2 choices for voters PPP and MQM and urdu speakers are not going to vote for bhuttoism since they imposed quota system on urban sindh.

PTI got votes from non-muhajirs. Trust me non-muhajirs rather vote for PPP then ethnic based target killing/bhatta khor party. Quota system isn’t that bad, its based on rural and urban population and not ethnicity.

what you wanted? Take up 95% of Sindh gov jobs because of urdu which was imposed on Sindhis? You realize there is merit based CSS exams where barely few % Karachites pass? Level playing field was need of the day. Now same system is needed for NA assembly seats.
 
PTI got votes from non-muhajirs. Trust me non-muhajirs rather vote for PPP then ethnic based target killing/bhatta khor party. Quota system isn’t that bad, its based on rural and urban population and not ethnicity.

what you wanted? Take up 95% of Sindh gov jobs because of urdu which was imposed on Sindhis? You realize there is merit based CSS exams where barely few % Karachites pass? Level playing field was need of the day. Now same system is needed for NA assembly seats.

I am sure many mohajirs voted for PTI during last polls.PTI candidates came 2nd position in many MQM sronghold areas like liaquatabad,azizabad,shah faisal etc as well as winning NA-250 which i beleieve includes saddar rown and posh areas like clifton and defence.Had there not been rigging than PTI might have won more seats.Every province has urban and rural areas but its only sindh that has separate quota for urban areas.Has the quota system benefitted rural sindh and its uplift.I am in favour of merit based system.
 
I am sure many mohajirs voted for PTI during last polls.PTI candidates came 2nd position in many MQM sronghold areas like liaquatabad,azizabad,shah faisal etc as well as winning NA-250 which i beleieve includes saddar rown and posh areas like clifton and defence.Had there not been rigging than PTI might have won more seats.Every province has urban and rural areas but its only sindh that has separate quota for urban areas.Has the quota system benefitted rural sindh and its uplift.I am in favour of merit based system.

Not many otherwise PTI would have won more seats, NA-250 is non-muhajir area. Other provinces urban-rural dynamics are not similar to Sindh.

What I'm proposing will fix Karachi and rangers will be moved out. Only fair representation is the way to go.

In merit based CSS system only 5% from Karachi passed.
 
Not many otherwise PTI would have won more seats, NA-250 is non-muhajir area. Other provinces urban-rural dynamics are not similar to Sindh.

What I'm proposing will fix Karachi and rangers will be moved out. Only fair representation is the way to go.

In merit based CSS system only 5% from Karachi passed.

i will say shut up. you dont have idea about Karachi. educated gentry of Karachi dont support MQM

Nazimabad, North Nazimabad, North karachi, Gulshan-e-Iqbal, DHA, Clifton, Vip malir Colony, Shah-r-Faisal etc dont support MQM. our votes used to cast already and when we reach at polling station to cast our votes we had to listen why you came here your vote has been already done. and when we complain to rangers they says. "our job is for security only outside. whatever is happening inside is not our responsibly"... MQM, PPP have many tricks to rig the election. why cant we introduce bio-metric system ? i think you belong to MQM

Again Shut up, You want ethnic building not Nation building
 
Last edited:
i will say shut up. you dont have idea about Karachi. educated gentry of Karachi dont support MQM

Nazimabad, North Nazimabad, North karachi, Gulshan-e-Iqbal, DHA, Clifton, Vip malir Colony, Shah-r-Faisal etc dont support MQM. our votes used to cast already and when we reach at polling station to cast our votes we had to listen why you came here your vote has been already done. and when we complain to rangers they says. "our job is for security only outside. whatever is happening inside is not our responsibly"... MQM, PPP have many tricks to rig the election especially. why cant we introduce bio-metric system ? i think you belong to MQM

Again Shut up, You want ethnic building not Nation building

What is wrong with fair representation of Karachi population? Why every seat most be won by only 1 ethnicity? This isn't fair to rest of people living there who have no voice.
 
What is wrong with fair representation of Karachi population? Why every seat most be won by only 1 ethnicity? This isn't fair to rest of people living there who have no voice.
then just get rid of the rigging, i am urdu speaking and hate ethnicity, i am Pakistani first. MQM won every election because MQM knows the trick of rigging. the only solution is to implement Bio-Matric system then sun will discover the filth under the white snow. then we would all have fair & real representation of every city of the country not just for Karachi only.

the biggest problem is rigging the election and unfortunately no one talk about it.
 
Last edited:
I’m for giving fair representation to Karachi people and here you are crying about ethnic division. You know what is ethnic BS? A racist bhatta khor ethnic based MQM win 95% of seats while being 40% of population.

Just like in rest of Pakistan, seats in Karachi too should be allocated to represent many ethnic groups of Karachi.



I’m sorry but do Karachi walas live on another planet and not in Karachi? MQM win 95% seats while being 40% of population. Punjabis don’t vote for MQM and neither Baloch because its ethnic party.

Now don’t give exemple of some baloch in MQM, he looked more like Bangladeshi with Baloch surname.



Bhaiyye please don’t be haramkhor like mullah Azad, Altaf Hussain etc. This isn’t punjab issue but Sindh and Karachi. Go put your muslim history in rear end. We are talking about Karachi here and how to fix its problems by dividing it along ethnic lines.

If bhattha khori is Pakistaniat then Altaf Hussain is one and true Pakistani.



This administrative BS will not fly anywhere. See how these stupid people are bringing punjab when it has nothing to do with it, clearly shows their hatered over no reason. To fix this Karachi should have representation from all quartes even if muhajirs still have more seats any other.

This will encourage more Sindhi to migrate to Karachi. Time to give Karachi back to Sindhis and aplogise for 1947 mistakes.

Maulana Azad was a haramkhor? He was one of the most respected people of his time and an extremely intelligent man.

Punjabi unionist party ki najaiz ulaad aur ghadaar Nwaz Sharif kay chamchay apni aukaat mai rhay. You bigoted fool it is very clear that you are racist and biased against urdu speakers and want to cut them in size. You should worry about how PML-N is trying to cut out Pathan vote in NA-120 Lahore. So, Lahore should be divided on ethnic lines. Karachi teray baap ka nahi hai jo tu uska thaikaydar bana hua hai. The future of Karachi will be decided by the people of Karachi not paindo haramkhors from Punjab who have been traitors of Pakistan from unionist party to mustafa khar and nawaz shariff.

"This will encourage more Sindhi to migrate to Karachi. Time to give Karachi back to Sindhis and aplogise for 1947 mistakes.[/QUOTE]"

The people who lived in Karachi before 1947 still live in Karachi haramkhor paindo maggot. Karachi never belonged to wadairas or people of interior Sindh. Most of it's resident were Hindus who migrated, Makranis, Gujratis and Parsis and they still live there. Stating that Karachi belong to someone from Larkana and not Muhajirs/Urdu speakers, who made Karachi the city it is today, and other residents of Karachi is beyond rational thinking and exposes that you are a paindoo Punjabi of a low upbringing.

What is wrong with fair representation of Karachi population? Why every seat most be won by only 1 ethnicity? This isn't fair to rest of people living there who have no voice.

Don't try to act innocent racist bigot. You do not know anything about politics in Karachi. You are wrong in your ill informed paindo assumption that only muhajir/urdu speakers vote for MQM. This is not true. Your concern for other ethnicities is borne out of hate for urdu speakers. If you are so concerned about Pathans why don't you open a thread on how their vote is being cut out of NA-120 elections and the discrimination against them in Lahore and other parts of your central Punjab.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Back
Top Bottom